IP Fridays - your intellectual property podcast about trademarks, patents, designs and much more
100 episodios
Interview With Angela Dunning, who defends Midjourney and Meta, explains where AI copyright litigation in the US stands and where it is heading – IP Fridays – Episode 180
30/10/2026 | 31 minI am Rolf Claessen and my co-host Ken Suzan and I are welcoming you to episode 180 of our podcast IP Fridays! Today’s interview guest is Angela Dunning, who defends Midjourney and Meta, and explains where AI copyright litigation in the US stands and where it is heading.
Profile of Angela Dunning: https://www.clearygottlieb.com/professionals/angela-l-dunning
But before we hear the interview, I have news for you!
On 19 October 2026, the US Supreme Court declined to hear Google’s appeal in Google v. VirtaMove. Google, backed by the computer and automotive industries, wanted to end the Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s practice of shielding older patents based on “settled expectations.” According to the amici, this practice led to the denial of 201 review petitions between June and October 2025. The Court followed the Solicitor General’s recommendation.
On 22 October 2026, the EUIPO and the European Commission published their IP enforcement report. In 2025, authorities seized more than 196 million counterfeit items worth €6.3 billion, 67 percent more than in 2024. Trademarks were the most frequently infringed right at 57 percent, followed by designs at 7 percent. By value of goods detained at the EU border, Germany ranked second behind Spain.
On 5 October 2026, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni filed a four-second recording of her voice saying “Io sono Giorgia Meloni” as a sound mark with the EUIPO. She wants to protect herself against AI voice clones and deepfakes. The application covers downloadable multimedia content and the organization of political rallies, among other things, and is currently under examination.
On 7 October 2026, the District Court of The Hague barred MSD from selling its subcutaneous cancer therapy Keytruda in eight European countries, including Belgium, France and Italy. The ruling came at the request of Halozyme Therapeutics. The court held patent EP 2 797 622 valid and infringed, even though MSD itself had started the proceedings with an action for a declaration of non-infringement.
On 2 October 2026, it emerged that Moderna has sued BioNTech and Pfizer over the vaccine Comirnaty before the UPC Local Division Hamburg (UPC-CFI-0003215/2026). According to JUVE Patent, it is the division’s first major life sciences case in a long time. Moderna relies on EP 3 981 437, after EPO Board of Appeal 3.3.08 revoked its core patent EP 3 590 949 for added matter in mid-September. Moderna is seeking damages rather than a sales ban.
On 28 September 2026, the US Senate Subcommittee on Intellectual Property questioned USPTO Director John Squires. The hearing focused on two topics: the Office’s authority to set its own fees, which expires on 12 December 2026, and the planned overhaul of proceedings before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. Squires said he is considering returning merits decisions to PTAB panels.
Generative AI on Trial: Angela Dunning on Fair Use, Trade Dress and a Monkey Selfie
More than 140 copyright lawsuits against AI developers are pending in the United States, and the first substantive rulings point toward fair use for training. In the latest episode of IP Fridays, my co-host Ken Suzan spoke with Angela Dunning, one of the lawyers defending those developers, about what courts have decided so far, which claims are still open and why she considers a trade dress claim over art styles a real risk for artists themselves.
Angela is a partner at Cleary Gottlieb in Silicon Valley. Her practice covers generative AI, copyright, trademark, technology and contract disputes, and Chambers ranks her for it. She has tried numerous cases to jury verdicts and won published IP appeals before the Ninth Circuit. In 2008 she worked as an assistant district attorney in San Francisco under then District Attorney Kamala Harris, and today she also teaches trademark law at UC Berkeley School of Law. She represents Midjourney and Meta in some of the most closely watched AI copyright cases in the country.
How a monkey led to the first AI training lawsuit
Angela’s path into AI litigation started about ten years ago with a crested macaque named Naruto. The monkey, from Sulawesi in Indonesia, had taken photographs of himself with a wildlife photographer’s camera. Those “monkey selfies” were later published through the self-publishing platform Blurb, Angela’s client, and Naruto (represented by animal rights advocates) sued for copyright infringement.
The case was funny on the surface and serious underneath. It raised the question of whether a non-human can be an author and have standing to sue under the Copyright Act. Angela knew even then that the answer would matter for generative AI, so her team paid close attention to how the human authorship requirement was framed. As she put it, losing to a monkey would have meant looking for a new job. The court held that copyright requires a human author, and the U.S. Copyright Office still cites that decision when it rejects registrations for AI-generated material.
The case also put Angela on the radar of AI developers. Since January 2023 she has defended Midjourney in Andersen, the first copyright class action in the United States aimed at the training of AI models. That case is moving toward the close of expert discovery and summary judgment within the next six to nine months. She also defends Meta in several putative class actions and direct actions over the training of its large language models, and she advises companies on the development and deployment of AI.
Training claims and output claims are two different fights
Angela splits the AI copyright litigation into two groups. Class actions against all the major developers attack the training of the models. In the putative class actions she handles, the plaintiffs don’t claim that any output is substantially similar to a work the model was trained on. The only question is whether copying works without permission to train a model that generates new, non-infringing content is a transformative fair use.
The second group consists of individual content owners who sue over training and over outputs. One example is a case against Midjourney brought by the owner of tens of thousands of registered copyrights in automobile photographs. Output claims bring back the classic questions of copyright litigation: whether the output is substantially similar to the original work and whether it harms the market for that work.
By Angela’s last count, more than 140 of these cases are pending across the United States. Despite that volume, courts have issued very few substantive rulings, and almost all of them at district court level. On the training question, no appellate court has spoken yet.
Kadrey v. Meta: training on books is fair use
Angela was part of the team that won an early summary judgment for Meta in Kadrey, a putative class action brought by book authors. Judge Chhabria held that Meta’s use of the plaintiffs’ books to train its Llama models was fair use as a matter of law.
On the first fair use factor, the purpose and character of the use, the court found the training of a model highly transformative. The decisive point came under the fourth factor, the effect on the market. The authors argued they had lost licensing fees for AI training. The court rejected that argument: an author has no claim to a license fee for a transformative use. A second route to market harm, infringing outputs, was closed because the plaintiffs never alleged that any output infringed their books.
Judge Chhabria then described a third theory himself, which he called market dilution. The idea is that AI models produce so much content that they flood the market and make it harder for authors to sell their own works. The plaintiffs had offered no evidence for that theory, so it couldn’t carry the day. It remains the theory that future plaintiffs will try to prove.
The second key holding concerns the source of the training data. The authors argued that Meta had obtained many books from so-called shadow libraries, websites that collected books without permission, and that this bad faith ruled out fair use. Judge Chhabria pointed to the Supreme Court’s decision in Google v. Oracle, which expressed doubt that good faith plays any role in fair use at all. Looking at the facts as a whole, he found that the source didn’t change the outcome: if a third party infringed the books when compiling its website, that doesn’t make Meta’s transformative use of them for training unfair. According to Angela, Kadrey was the first ruling to address this question in that way, and it conflicts with Judge Alsup’s ruling in Bartz v. Anthropic, issued a day and a half earlier.
Kadrey isn’t over: new plaintiffs, a trial date in April 2027
The summary judgment did not end the case. A separate claim remains on whether Meta distributed the works through the download method it allegedly used, and it is still being litigated. In the meantime, further authors and publishers have filed their own direct actions and competing class actions. Several of them were filed in New York and have now been transferred to California, where Judge Chhabria will hear them together with Kadrey.
These new plaintiffs are trying again to establish a training-based infringement claim, and this time they are preparing the evidence of market harm under the fourth factor that the Kadrey plaintiffs failed to deliver. Summary judgment proceedings are expected in the new year, and Judge Chhabria has set trial for April 2027. Anyone who wants to know whether market dilution will hold up as a theory of harm should watch this courtroom.
Can an art style be protected as trade dress?
The most unusual claim in the AI litigation landscape comes from trademark law. In Andersen, the artists accuse Midjourney of vicarious trade dress infringement under the Lanham Act. As far as Angela knows, Midjourney is the only AI company facing such a claim based on image outputs.
The claim is the plaintiffs’ second attempt to protect their style. Their original complaint relied on copyright, but copyright law excludes styles, ideas, concepts and facts and protects only their concrete expression. A right of publicity claim based on the same art styles failed as well, because the court held it preempted by the Copyright Act when ruling on Midjourney’s first motion to dismiss. In the amended complaint, the plaintiffs switched to trade dress. Their theory: when users prompt Midjourney to generate images in the style of a particular artist, the outputs infringe that artist’s trade dress, and Midjourney is secondarily liable.
Angela sees the greatest danger in how broadly the plaintiffs define their styles. One plaintiff claims trade dress in simple black-and-white cartoons, a style thousands of artists used long before her. Another paints realistic fantasy pictures of dragons and would effectively hold an exclusive right to that subject matter. If courts accepted styles like these as trade dress, every artist would have to wonder with every new work whether someone else could claim to have used that style first.
Trademark law adds further hurdles. The functionality doctrine bars trademark protection for functional features of a product, and the sole function of an artwork is its aesthetic. The plaintiffs also have to prove secondary meaning, meaning that the public associates the style with a single source. Angela’s strongest argument comes from art history: entire movements grew out of artists building on the styles of others. Nobody would claim that Picasso alone was allowed to paint in a Cubist style, but the trade dress theory points exactly in that direction. The claim will be tested at summary judgment.
The debate moves from training to outputs
With Kadrey and Bartz v. Anthropic, two courts have now held that using works to train a large language model is transformative and fair use. Angela expects the litigation focus to move to output claims. Major rights holders such as The New York Times and large publishing houses have sued over vast amounts of their own content and can assert output claims on a scale that individual authors can’t. On training, Angela sees the direction of travel heading toward fair use.
The Ninth Circuit has closed another line of attack. In Doe 1 v. GitHub, decided about a month before the recording, the court addressed claims under Section 1202 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Plaintiffs had argued that AI outputs violate the DMCA because they don’t carry the copyright management information of the authors whose works were used in training. The Ninth Circuit held that the outputs of generative AI models are different works from the training material, even where they contain verbatim code or other content from it. A Section 1202 claim therefore doesn’t lie. Plaintiffs had raised this claim in many of the pending class actions, district courts had dismissed it almost everywhere, and after this decision it stays out.
The tone in the creative industries has changed too. Content owners who used to warn that AI would harm them now announce their own models. Film studios use AI in production, publishers build their own tools, and news organizations partner with AI developers or develop tools in-house. Angela describes the new consensus as acceptance: the technology is here to stay and helps people who create content work more effectively and faster.
A new category of lawsuits has grown over the past year that has nothing to do with intellectual property. These cases concern what Angela calls real-world harms: outputs that give users wrong information or lead them to harm themselves, intentionally or not. She expects the next wave of litigation to focus on what AI outputs actually contain and how people use these tools in everyday life.
A lot of work for human IP lawyers
When Ken asked where we will be in one or two years, Angela gave a clear answer: there will be plenty of work for human IP lawyers. She calls herself an optimist and wants every side at the table to find out together how this technology can serve people. AI already helps find diseases and develop cures, and it will create new forms of expression and new ways to tell stories, which is exactly what copyright law was meant to promote. If everyone works in good faith, keeps each other honest and uses the technology responsibly, she believes that a year from now some of today’s concerns will be resolved and new opportunities will have opened up for many people.
The full conversation with Angela Dunning is available in the current episode of IP Fridays. If your company uses generative AI for product designs, marketing images or code and you want to know what these US decisions mean for your own trademarks, designs and copyrights in Europe, contact me directly. One initial call is enough to find out where your company stands.
Here is the full transcript of the interview:
Kenneth Suzan: Thank you, Rolf. Our guest today on the IP Fridays podcast is Angela Dunning. Angela is a partner with Cleary Gottlieb and is based in their Silicon Valley office in California. Angela’s Chambers-recognized practice focuses on generative AI, copyright, trademark, technology, contract disputes, and other complex commercial litigation for the world’s top companies.
She has tried numerous cases to a jury verdict and has substantial experience in the federal appellate courts, including successful arguments before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in high-profile published IP cases. In 2008, Angela served as an assistant district attorney in San Francisco under then District Attorney Kamala Harris. Angela teaches trademark law at UC Berkeley School of Law and is a thought leader and frequent speaker on AI and IP issues. Welcome, Angela, to the IP Fridays podcast.
Angela Dunning: It’s great to be here, Ken. Thanks so much for having me.
Kenneth Suzan: Angela, you are working on some of the most significant copyright and trademark cases of the day related to generative AI. How did you get involved?
Angela Dunning: Oh, well, it all goes back to a monkey, if you can believe it. About ten years ago, a crested macaque from Sulawesi, Indonesia, named Naruto filed a copyright lawsuit against my client Blurb, which was a self-publishing platform used by a human photographer to publish what have now become known as the monkey selfies: photographs that the macaques took of themselves when he was trying to film them in the wild in Indonesia.
You don’t get a case like that every day. It was a matter that comes around once in a lifetime. I had done some work for Blurb earlier, and when this came across my desk, I knew it would be fun, but also significant, because there was a key issue of human authorship and standing to assert a copyright claim. There was also, already at that time, some good literature on what the implications of that would be in the context of generative AI.
So I was very mindful, as we were litigating that case, of how the human authorship requirement should be described and how that would affect the potential authorship and copyrightability issues in the context of AI. We just didn’t know how quickly those questions would need to be answered. The resulting ruling in that case was that human authorship is required, and that decision continues to be cited by the U.S. Copyright Office today in its decisions around copyrightability.
It also brought me to the attention of some AI developers, including my client Midjourney, which was named in the first copyright class action lawsuit in the U.S. directed to the training of AI models. I’ve been working on that one since January of 2023, and it’s been a long, interesting road since then.
Kenneth Suzan: Yeah, that monkey selfie case has been around for a while. People have been talking about it for many years.
Angela Dunning: Yeah, you don’t have a client sued by a monkey every day. And it presented certain challenges, because if you win, you get the result everyone expects. If you lose to a monkey, you really need to find a new job. So I’m happy to say I lived to fight another day.
Kenneth Suzan: Yes. Now, Angela, what are some of the cases you’re currently working on that you can share with us?
Angela Dunning: Sure. It’s public record that I am representing Midjourney in the Andersen class action I just mentioned, which is continuing to be litigated. We’re headed toward the close of expert discovery and summary judgment in the coming six to nine months.
I’ve also been very privileged to work on a series of copyright actions, both putative class actions and direct actions, against Meta related to the training of its large language models. And I advise quite a few companies in the space on deployment and development. But those are the public matters that I can share.
Kenneth Suzan: And in your opinion, what are the most critical issues to be decided in those cases currently being litigated?
Angela Dunning: Across the spectrum of generative AI copyright litigation, the central issue is obviously going to be fair use: whether it constitutes a transformative fair use to train on copyrighted materials without authorization to make a model that can generate new and non-infringing content. In the putative class actions that I’m handling, the claims are directed to training. They’re not directed to outputs, and there is no claim that any output is substantially similar to any material on which the model was trained.
There’s a variety of additional cases, however. I have another action that’s been filed against Midjourney by the owner of tens of thousands of copyright registrations for automobile photographs, and there are output claims in that case. So what we’re seeing are class action lawsuits directed at all the major developers that are focused on training, and then individual content creators filing suits that are directed not only to training, but also to outputs.
Across the training cases, plainly, fair use is going to be an issue. When you start getting into outputs, there are all sorts of traditional questions at play. Is there substantial similarity between the outputs at issue and the copyrighted original works? Has there been any sort of harm to the market for those works?
We’ve seen no shortage of cases filed. I think at last count we’re up to over 140 cases pending across the country. Some rulings are around the corner in some of those cases, but there have been very few substantive rulings to date, and mostly only at the district court level. So there’s still a lot to be done.
Kenneth Suzan: Now, Angela, you represent Meta in the Kadrey putative class action, where the court issued an early summary judgment ruling of fair use. What did the court decide?
Angela Dunning: The judge in our case, Judge Chhabria, held in the Kadrey suit that Meta’s use of plaintiffs’ books to train its Llama models was fair use as a matter of law. The court found that training a model is highly transformative under the first factor of fair use, which looks at the nature of the use. It also found that plaintiffs had failed to come forward with any evidence that the market for their works had been harmed by Meta’s use of their works for training.
Plaintiffs had argued that the use of their works had deprived them of a licensing fee for training, and the court held that they were not entitled to a license for that use because it was transformative. There were no allegations, as I mentioned, that any of the outputs were infringing, so they couldn’t point to harm in that respect. The court then identified a third theory they could have pursued, which it called market dilution, the theory being that so much content is being generated using Meta’s models that it is flooding the market and making it hard for plaintiffs to sell their works into that market. But plaintiffs had come forward with no evidence to support that kind of new theory of factor four harm. So on balance, the court found that summary judgment for Meta was warranted as a matter of law.
There was also another important holding in the case, which conflicts with one that Judge Alsup reached in Bartz v. Anthropic just a day and a half earlier: that the source of the data downloaded for training didn’t affect the analysis. The plaintiffs in Kadrey had argued that the fact that Meta sourced many books from what they called shadow websites, which had compiled lots of books without permission, indicated that Meta’s use was made in bad faith and precluded a fair use finding.
Citing the Supreme Court’s statement in Google v. Oracle that there’s reason to doubt whether good faith has any role to play in fair use, and looking at the facts holistically, Judge Chhabria found that it didn’t move the needle in this case. The fact that some third party may have infringed plaintiffs’ works in compiling their website didn’t mean that Meta’s transformative use of those materials to train a model wasn’t fair. That was a significant ruling, and really the first to address that issue in that way.
Kenneth Suzan: And what’s the current status of the Kadrey case following the summary judgment ruling?
Angela Dunning: There was a separate claim with respect to the potential distribution of those works through the download method that Meta was alleged to have used, and that claim has proceeded. The Kadrey case has since been related to a series of additional suits. A number of authors and publishers have filed either direct claims or competing copyright class actions. Several of those were filed in New York and, after briefing, have recently been ordered transferred to California to be related and heard by Judge Chhabria as well.
So Kadrey is proceeding alongside other cases that are trying anew to establish a training-based copyright infringement claim. Plaintiffs in those cases are trying their hand at making the factor four market harm showing that the Kadrey plaintiffs were unable to make. There’s a lot going on. Summary judgment [is expected] in the new year, and Judge Chhabria just set trial for April of 2027.
Kenneth Suzan: Interesting. I’m sure we’ll be tracking that quite closely in the coming year. Let’s shift gears now, Angela, and talk about trademarks. Are you seeing any interesting trademark issues arising in your cases?
Angela Dunning: Yes, I think there’s a really interesting Lanham Act claim in the Andersen class action we’re defending for Midjourney. It’s the only company I’m aware of that is facing a vicarious trade dress infringement claim based on image outputs.
In their original complaint, the plaintiffs had asserted a copyright claim based on use of their art style, and style is not protectable under copyright law. Style, facts, ideas and concepts are by law excluded from copyright protection, which extends only to the expression of an idea or fact. They had also asserted a right of publicity claim premised on use of their art style, and that claim was deemed preempted by the Copyright Act in the first order on our motion to dismiss.
So in lieu of those claims, plaintiffs added a claim for vicarious trade dress infringement in the amended complaint. The theory is that when users prompt Midjourney’s platform to generate images [in the style] of particular artists, the outputs necessarily infringe those artists’ trade dress, and that Midjourney should be held secondarily liable for this.
There are a number of problems with that theory. The most obvious is that the plaintiffs’ claimed art styles are so broad and amorphous as to create some real risk, frankly, to artists themselves, should those be found to constitute protectable trade dress. One of the plaintiffs asserts trade dress in, basically, simple black-and-white cartoons. That describes an art style used by thousands of artists, long before she used it. Another plaintiff paints fantasy paintings of dragons. Again, he’s not the first to do that and won’t be the last.
The notion that he and he alone should be able to paint realistic paintings of dragons should be cause for concern for all artists, who would then need to be looking over their shoulder on every work they ever create to see if somebody might say they used that art style first and that it somehow points to them.
I think there’s also a really interesting functionality issue, Ken, because an artwork’s sole function is its aesthetic. If you can extend trademark protection to what is in effect a functional attribute of a product, that creates real issues. And there are loads of other interesting trademark issues. There’s a problem with secondary meaning and whether plaintiffs will be able to establish it.
But the big concern is what this means. We have whole art movements premised on artists building on styles introduced by others, even styles with which those artists are indelibly connected: Picasso and Cubism, for instance. Nobody would dare suggest that Picasso, and Picasso alone, is entitled to paint in a Cubist style. But to some extent, that is what plaintiffs are asserting in this case. We will see how those claims resolve as we make our way through summary judgment.
Kenneth Suzan: Thanks so much, Angela. We’re coming near the end of our podcast. Final question: have you observed any shift in the conversation around generative AI?
Angela Dunning: Yes, I think that has absolutely occurred. For years now, a huge focus has been on the copyright claims. Now, with two decisions behind us, in Kadrey and in Bartz v. Anthropic, holding that the use of materials for training a large language model is transformative and fair use, I think some of the focus has shifted to the cases asserting output-based claims.
We have major content creators and owners like The New York Times, major publishing houses and others that have filed lawsuits over large swaths of content they own, where they can assert, and are asserting, output-based claims. I think we’re going to see more focus there in the litigation, as the direction of travel on the training-based claims is toward fair use.
We also saw an important decision earlier this year out of the Ninth Circuit on another flavor of copyright claim under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act: the claim that outputs of AI models that do not include copyright management information for the authors whose works were used for training violate Section 1202 of the DMCA. The court held in Doe 1 v. GitHub, just about a month ago now, that the outputs of generative AI models are in fact different works from those on which the model was trained, even if they incorporate verbatim code or other content from the training material, and that a claim will not lie for those works not including the copyright management information of the authors of the training materials.
That claim had been asserted in numerous of the currently pending copyright class actions and had been rejected and dismissed in almost all of those cases. It will remain out.
Then, just in terms of the conversation, you have the major content creators whose presentations are shifting from “AI is bad and this is going to harm us” to “we’re going to build our own models.” Studios are using it, of course, to aid in the creation of film. You have publishing houses that are building, and news organizations that are partnering with developers or developing tools in-house. So I think there has been a shift toward acceptance that the technology is here, that it has tremendous potential to help those who are creating content do so more effectively and more quickly, and that these are powerful tools that are here to stay.
Over the last year or so, we have also seen a focus away from the IP-related issues toward what I would call real-world harms: claims that the outputs are harming users, providing faulty information, or leading users to harm themselves, either intentionally or unintentionally. So as we sit back and look at what is likely still to come down the pike, we’re going to see a focus on what the outputs actually consist of and how people are interacting with these tools in everyday life.
Kenneth Suzan: Angela, this is fantastic, and I really appreciate you sharing your insights into the litigation that’s going on. Where do you think we’ll be a year or two from now? More of the same, or some new things down the pike?
Angela Dunning: Well, look, I think there’s going to be an awful lot of work for human IP lawyers to do over the next few years. I don’t see that going anywhere. And I am a big believer in all of us coming together, and that means every constituency, from every perspective, to figure out how to make this powerful, really incredible new technology work for us as human beings.
I’m an optimist by nature, Ken. I stay on top of the news, and I am aware that there are real challenges. But I think we’ve got to keep talking about it, because this technology already is helping us find new diseases and also new cures. It’s going to help us create new expression. It’s going to let us tell stories in new ways, which is, after all, what copyright law was meant to promote.
If we all work together in good faith to keep everybody honest, but also to harness the power of this technology and get it right, I’m really hopeful that a year from now we’ll have mastered some of the things we’re concerned about and opened up new opportunities for lots of people.
Kenneth Suzan: Thank you, Angela, so much for spending time with us on the IP Fridays podcast.
Angela Dunning: Oh, thanks a lot for having me. It was great to be with you. Thank you, everybody.Interview with Peter Berg – Chief IP Counsel at Infineon Technologies and VPP President – Building Litigation Ready Patents – Politics, Acquisitions, NPEs and Post Quantum Cryptography – Why He Wants Germany’s Inventor Law Gone – IP Fridays Podcast – Episode 179
25/09/2026 | 52 minMy co-host Ken Suzan and I are welcoming you to episode 179 of our podcast IP Fridays! Today’s Interview guest is Peter Berg. If you don’t know Peter, he is the Chief IP Counsel at Infineon Technologies and is also serving as the VPP president. We talk about the industry association of in-house practitioners VPP, politics, patent strategy at Infineon, litigation ready patents, NPEs, acquisitions, the German emloyees invention act and many more things. So stay with us for this very interesting interview.
Before we jump into this interview, I have news for you!
The USPTO has issued its first AI-related disciplinary action, published on August 27, 2026 in In re Brian E. Mitchell (Proceeding No. D2026-16) before the Office of Enrollment and Discipline. The underlying settlement was signed by the attorney on July 20, 2026 and by the OED Director on July 21, 2026, with final approval given on July 27, 2026 by Tricia Choe on behalf of USPTO Director John A. Squires. The action resulted in a public reprimand against California patent attorney Brian E. Mitchell after a generative AI tool produced a claim comparison chart containing fabricated citations to the patent’s internal file history. The case underscores that AI-generated hallucinations must be verified by a human before filing.
InterDigital has escalated its patent dispute with Disney across three fronts within a month. On August 25, 2026, InterDigital filed two new actions at the Unified Patent Court: a preliminary injunction request at the Mannheim Local Division (UPC_CFI_3044/2026) and a main infringement action at the Düsseldorf Local Division (UPC_CFI_3043/2026), covering Germany, France and the Netherlands. Both target Disney+ Premium’s switch to the VP9 video codec, which InterDigital says still infringes patent EP 2 465 265, a patent the Mannheim division had already found valid and infringed in an earlier ruling that also branded Disney an unwilling licensee; the Düsseldorf action adds a second patent, EP 2 605 473, covering the Up Next continue-watching feature. On September 2, 2026, the Düsseldorf Local Division granted InterDigital an injunction against Disney covering Germany and the Netherlands over a separate patent protecting seamless playback continuation when switching between devices, upholding the patent’s validity in the same ruling. It was InterDigital’s third UPC injunction against Disney. Then, on September 15, 2026, InterDigital filed a damages claim for EUR 101.7 million against Disney at the Munich Regional Court I (case no. 7 O 8870/26), based on a November 2025 finding that Disney+ infringes InterDigital’s HDR video patent EP 2 132 923; the claim also covers viewers in 19 European countries served through a Frankfurt-based server location. For companies relying on codec or connectivity technology, the dispute is a reminder that switching to a different standard does not automatically avoid infringement if the asserted patent is drafted broadly enough.
The EPO’s Enlarged Board of Appeal ruled on September 3, 2026 in G 1/25 that a patent description only needs to be amended to match amended claims if a discrepancy between the two causes a requirement of the EPC, such as clarity, novelty or inventive step, not to be met.
The EPO’s Board of Appeal 3.3.08 fully revoked Moderna’s key mRNA patent EP 3 590 949 following a two-day hearing that concluded in mid-September 2026, on the grounds that the claimed subject matter extended beyond the original application. The revocation removes the basis for Moderna’s earlier wins against BioNTech and Pfizer in Düsseldorf and London.
On September 15, 2026, US sportswear maker New Balance filed a trademark suit against Decathlon’s US units, Decathlon America LLC and Decathlon USA LLC, in the US District Court for the District of Massachusetts (case no. 1:26-cv-14235). New Balance argues that the K logo on its Kiprun running shoe line, when mirrored, reads unmistakably as an N and imitates the N mark it has used for roughly 50 years, claiming post-sale confusion.
On September 8, 2026, the Court of Justice of the EU ruled in Case C-298/23, Inter IKEA Systems v Vrijheidsfonds, on a referral from the Brussels Enterprise Court, that the owner of a well-known trademark can prohibit its use by a political party unless the party sets out the specific reasons why its freedom of expression outweighs the trademark owner’s interests. The case arose from the Vlaams Belang party’s 2022 campaign promoting a migration plan styled as IKEA assembly instructions.
And now for the interview with Peter Berg!
In this episode of IP Fridays I talk with Peter Berg. He is Chief IP Counsel at Infineon Technologies and President of VPP, the German association for in house IP professionals, since May 2025. Berg is an electrical engineer by training and leads a team at Infineon that manages a portfolio of more than 12,000 patent families, while the company simultaneously enforces its rights offensively in Germany, the US and China. That combination of hands on portfolio work and association leadership makes him one of the rare guests who can speak to both the operational detail of one of Europe’s largest patent portfolios and the political side of Germany’s IP landscape.
The guest: Peter Berg and the VPP
Peter Berg is an electrical engineer who became Chief IP Counsel at Infineon Technologies and, since May 2025, President of the VPP, the association representing in house patent professionals in Germany. His team manages a portfolio of more than 12,000 patent families while running an offensive enforcement program across Germany, the US and China. That mix of operational and political experience is exactly why I wanted him on the podcast.
Germany’s national IP strategy: more than a promise on paper
I asked Berg what has become of the national IP strategy promised in Germany’s coalition agreement, and what happens if it does not materialize during this legislative term. His answer was clear. The question is no longer whether the strategy will arrive, only how comprehensive it turns out to be. If it falls short of what industry needs, the profession will simply push for adjustments afterward.
Berg names three levels that need attention. First, society as a whole, from kindergarten to retirement, needs to understand that intellectual property underpins our prosperity rather than being a line item in the accounts. Second, academia and professional education. Third, startups and the broader Mittelstand, where well funded structures are still missing. The German Patent and Trademark Office has an educational mandate but far too small a budget for it, and the regional patent information centers are underfunded as well. Berg makes a point that is easy to miss from outside Germany: the patent office reports to the Ministry of Justice rather than to an innovation focused ministry, even though its real purpose is to strengthen the economy. That three ministries, research, economy and justice, are now working on the strategy together strikes him as genuine progress.
Litigation ready patents: how Infineon manages 12,000 patent families
Infineon has roughly tripled its turnover since 2017 while keeping portfolio size largely stable. The answer, Berg says, is quality over quantity. Inventors pitch their ideas to a panel of senior technical experts and patent attorneys, and the process does not stop there. The draft itself is reviewed by multiple stakeholders, and once the notice of allowance arrives and the patent is granted, it goes through another review. The criteria stay consistent throughout: technology assessment, market size, detectability, circumventability and fit with Infineon’s own roadmap.
Internal discipline alone does not make a patent litigation ready, though. That requires real experience with conflict, and most of that experience comes from the defensive side, where Infineon has plenty of practice finding weaknesses in patents asserted against it. Being on the offensive, Berg says, is a different level of learning entirely, whether in court or in licensing negotiations where the other side is not sure it would get a fair outcome if the case went to trial.
In practice this also means systematic pruning. Internally Infineon calls the relevant phases US8 and US12, the years when annuity costs peak in the US portfolio, by far the most expensive part of the estate. Berg says his team knows every one of the more than 12,000 patent families in detail, and offensive enforcement is focused on the markets that matter most for electronic products: Germany, the US and China.
An injunction at a trade show: national courts versus the UPC
One concrete trigger for this conversation was an ex parte preliminary injunction Infineon obtained at a German trade show, without the defendant having filed a protective letter in advance. For Berg, enforcement at trade fairs is nothing new, it has been part of the playbook for years, now extended to venues outside Europe that Western companies have used less often in the past.
His view on the UPC is nuanced. He credits the court with a strong start, good management and judges selected for quality rather than politics, and praises the body of case law it has built in a little over three years. On the other hand, some member states are still missing, a comprehensive body of case law takes time to develop, and costs do not fit every business case, especially where achievable damages barely justify the expense. Infineon in any case validates most European patents in only a handful of countries rather than dozens, so the practical difference between national and UPC enforcement is smaller than it might seem. For smaller cases the option to opt out and litigate nationally alongside UPC rights remains important, even though systematically double patenting is not something Infineon pursues for cost reasons.
Four systems at once: coordinating cross border enforcement
Infineon’s legal and patent departments have grown together over 25 years into a fully integrated international organization, with teams in Europe, North America and several Asian countries that, by Berg’s account, communicate on close to a weekly basis. Add to that a strong network of outside counsel. The commitment to management is not to shy away from any jurisdiction where the need arises.
Berg is careful that patent attorneys do not spend their entire careers doing only litigation or only prosecution. Attorneys who rotate into a litigation team bring that experience back into their regular business support afterward, and that cycle in turn improves the quality of new filings. Litigation has become part of daily business, but never something a team slides into unprepared. Going on the offensive against a competitor requires planning several steps ahead.
IP due diligence in practice: the Marvell Brightlane deal
I found Berg’s answer on the Marvell Brightlane acquisition, Infineon’s 2.5 billion dollar deal for Marvell’s automotive Ethernet business that closed in August 2025, particularly revealing. In the semiconductor industry, he explains, IP is rarely primarily the patent portfolio. What matters more are frozen technologies and so called IP blocks, reusable design blocks that enable fast product development. Infineon almost never acquires a company because of its patents. Being a large, established player, its own portfolio is usually broad enough to secure a new technical area against incumbent competitors.
The real work starts after signing. It means listening without being pushy, understanding the new colleagues’ processes and tools before deciding how to integrate the portfolio. Since none of Marvell’s IP staff joined Infineon in this deal, the team had to build up portfolio expertise using the acquired engineers and set up an operational patent committee, then plan which areas of the portfolio were already strong and where investment was still needed. The faster that integration decision gets made, Berg says, the better, because product development can never be allowed to stall because of an acquisition.
The Cypress lesson: NPE exposure from legacy portfolios
One risk many companies underestimate in acquisitions is patents an acquired business sold to a non practicing entity, or NPE, before the deal closed. That happened with Cypress Semiconductor in 2016, after its merger with Spansion left it with an oversized portfolio it did not need. Cypress sold around 2,000 patents to the NPE organization IP Value, and only a few years later Infineon acquired Cypress. Because the sale included a retained license for Cypress’s own business, Berg sees no exposure for Infineon from those specific patents today.
The broader issue of NPE enforcement, though, remains real. Realistically there are many dozens of new cases a month, often directed at customers or the wider ecosystem rather than at chipmakers directly. Even when Infineon is not the target, it has to support its customers whenever its own technology is implicated. For the industry as a whole this consumes a great deal of resources without moving innovation forward, a point that comes up especially often at this time of year in Munich, when IP practitioners from around the world gather for meetings.
Post quantum cryptography: patent density ahead of standardization
In December 2024 Infineon became the first company to achieve a CC EAL6 certification in post quantum cryptography, one of the highest security certifications available. Berg describes two angles to the work. On one side, Infineon develops its own chipsets to enable quantum computing itself, already a real business rather than pure research. On the other side, customers across Infineon’s application fields need to be prepared for what he calls quantum day, the point at which powerful quantum computers become available, including to bad actors. Because that day may only be three to five years away, infrastructure needs to be built now so it can handle new cryptographic approaches.
On standard essentiality he is measured rather than evasive. There are certainly patents in this field from Infineon and others, but security standards have historically leaned toward royalty free licensing rather than the large patent clusters seen in cellular communication from 2G through 5G. Whether that pattern repeats for post quantum cryptography, he cannot say, but Infineon is preparing for either outcome.
Germany’s Employee Invention Act: opportunity or burden
Asked whether Germany’s Employee Invention Act is an opportunity or a burden for the country’s innovation ecosystem, Berg does not hold back. With more than 30 years of experience, he estimates that 99 percent of all inventions are simply the regular work product of engineers in R&D, requiring no extra incentive at all. In countries without an equivalent law, employees are demonstrably just as innovative and just as willing to share their inventions with the company.
His core objection is that invention does not equal innovation. Procurement, production, quality management and many other functions all contribute to a product’s success, not just the named inventors. That the inventor alone receives extra compensation while everyone else does not strikes Berg as unfair, especially since Infineon already rewards its top engineers appropriately regardless of statutory requirements. He calls the law a bureaucratic nightmare that should be abolished or at least radically simplified. Smaller organizations, he notes, often just ignore it or implement it badly, and every company Infineon has acquired with German operations has come with its own legacy mess to clean up.
Artificial intelligence in day to day patent work at Infineon
On AI, Berg describes three layers. The first is established tools: patent search, translation between the team’s main working languages, and, for about two years now, drafting replies to office actions. As with any tool, the benefit only shows up with repeated use at real volume, which is why Infineon works deliberately with outside counsel to broaden adoption across the team.
The second layer is ongoing testing of new tools, limited mainly by the time available to evaluate them. The third is everyday office use. Since spring 2025, everyone from paralegals to attorneys has been able to use AI tools broadly within a secure environment. The bar stays the same throughout: if AI output is not at least as good as an attorney’s prior work, it is not worth using, or the cleanup afterward eats up any time saved. Where it does work, responses to standardization proposals, for instance, can be produced far faster. One question Berg expects to face next year, without yet having an answer: how should efficiency gains be split between the company and outside counsel once both sides benefit from AI?
Three messages for the IP community
I closed by asking Berg for the most important messages he would want to give our listeners, mostly IP professionals in companies and law firms. His first message: think about IP strategy from the end, starting with what needs to be asserted against whom and for what purpose in ten or twenty years, rather than letting today’s deadlines dictate everything. Only that kind of multi year plan, combined with a sound cost benefit ratio, produces genuinely litigation ready patents.
His second message is again about artificial intelligence: anyone who has not started training with it yet risks missing the wave, and this is not a skill built overnight. His third message is aimed at anyone not yet connected to peers in the profession: use the associations and networks that already exist to build that exchange, a thought that ties neatly back to the VPP, where our conversation began.
And here is the full transcript:
Peter Berg: Hi, I’m Peter Berg, Chief IP Counsel at Infineon Technologies and President of VPP, the Association of In-house Patent Practitioners in Germany. And you are listening to IP Fridays.
Rolf Claessen: Today’s interview guest is Peter Berg.
If you don’t know Peter, he is an electrical engineer by training and is the Chief IP Counsel at Infineon Technologies and also serving as the VPP president. Thank you very much for being on IP Fridays.
Peter Berg: My pleasure.
Rolf Claessen: So first I want to talk about VPP. You succeeded Beat Weibel from Siemens as VPP president in May 2024 and have publicly called for Germany to finally deliver on the coalition agreement promise of the national IP strategy. So politics, what are the two or three most concrete things that strategy must contain? What happens if it doesn’t get done in this legislative period?
Peter Berg: First of all, I think I need to correct you. It was May 2025, so not that long as a standing president. But if you mention national IP strategy, national means here for Germany. I think the question isn’t anymore whether or what happens if we don’t get that strategy. I think that is now on its way. The question is rather how good and comprehensive the national IP strategy will be, and if it’s just not enough from an industry perspective, I would say then we adjust afterwards. Of course, there is a big paper out from the BDI, the German Industry Association, published in 2024, and I need to focus on something which is really close to my heart. If you ask me the main content it should have, it is first of all better IP education, and I see there are kind of three levels. One is really society as such, so each and everybody from kindergarten to retirees, we need to acknowledge in the knowledge society that IP is central for our well-being. We have to respect the IP of others. We have to be proud to create IP, not just treat it as an entry in the accounts. Yeah, society at large. The second level is really academia and education in our professional environment. And finally, life is difficult for startups, people who want to create a new company, and small and medium-sized enterprises. There is good stuff out there. The German Patent and Trademark Office has a mandate to educate, but a very small budget to do so. In a federal country like Germany, there are local support systems, be it the chambers of commerce or the patent information centers. The structure is there, but it’s underfinanced, and Germany has to gear up on that one. So besides IP education, I believe solid national IP institutions are key. This is also a funding issue, be it headcount or technology. Think of the German Patent and Trademark Office, think of the courts, be it on the infringement side or the nullity side, so the Federal Patent Court. We need to back up nationally the European institutions, since we believe not every case is worth taking to the UPC, so for smaller cases we need a good national system as a backup. And government needs to have that in mind and not rely too much on European institutions alone. Finally, facilitate the IP transfer from universities and research institutions into industry. Right now it’s all about startups, et cetera, but that kind of IP transfer starts first of all with people leaving university, leaving those research institutions and joining industry, be it as staff or through research contracts. And finally, of course, startups are the area where Germany needs to catch up in particular. Perhaps I need to add for non-German listeners, there is a particularity in Germany in that the IP institutions, like the Patent and Trademark Office, report into the Ministry of Justice, although it’s an instrument for thriving innovation and building a solid economy. So it’s right now a totally new thing for this country that three ministries, research, economy and justice, are working together on this national IP strategy, with only recently some good progress.
Rolf Claessen: You’ve said publicly that Infineon’s primary focus is patents that provide clear competitive advantages, and that for you it’s about litigation-ready patents. That’s a very specific phrase. How do you define it operationally, and how has the pruning of your more than 12,000-family portfolio changed in the last two years?
Peter Berg: Yeah, I think that’s a process which lasted much more than two years, and it’s never over. This is work in progress. Thinking back to 2017, I joined Infineon, and the company has developed very nicely since. I think we roughly tripled turnover but kept the portfolio size roughly stable, despite acquisitions, despite that growth, also in R&D, et cetera. We’ve even been able to shrink costs since then, and I believe we’ve achieved our strategic goals, now with a good, or let’s say not yet good enough, cost-benefit ratio. And the answer to that equation is quality. Now, we as patent practitioners might call it differently, but at the end it comes down to the fact that, most likely for all companies and for practitioners who support companies in private practice, you need a collaboration platform. That means for Infineon, the inventors are key. They are involved in decision-making, so they pitch their invention to senior technical experts, my team members, and patent attorneys, and the quality of that expert panel makes a big difference. Then come repetitive reviews, not just once the decision to file is taken, but the draft itself is also reviewed by multiple stakeholders. Then we get the notice of allowance, the patent is granted, another review, and later on we try to apply consistent criteria: what’s the technology assessment, what’s the market size, is it detectable, is it easy to circumvent, et cetera, and does it fit with our own roadmap. And of course it would be nice if you could easily compare it with a competitor’s roadmap, or take the time to speculate on certain market changes which might be disruptive. And I believe if you apply that consistently over a sufficiently long period, you get patents you could call litigation-grade or litigation-ready. What is then missing, though, is real experience with conflicts against competitors and how the courts look at that. So the truth comes out once you go to court. On the defensive side, of course, we have tons of experience trying to find weaknesses in patents being asserted against Infineon, et cetera. But I think it’s another level of learning to be on the offensive, and that might play out in court, but it might also play out in licensing negotiations, where the other side is sufficiently unsure whether they would get an outcome they believe would be fair if they went to court with those patents. You asked me about the pruning of all this. So what is our approach there? There is a kind of forced pruning rate which we believe is necessary, to make it mandatory for everybody to identify the weakest patents in the respective portfolios. We focus on the years where costs are highest, what we internally call US8 and US12, since a big chunk of money needs to be spent on annuity payments for the US portfolio, which is the dominant one, and for the rest of the world it’s rather towards the end of the patents’ lifecycle. Now, having a good team, people who really like the technology and stay in charge for a long time, I could proudly say that my team knows every one of those 12,000 patent families well, and not just on the German or the US side, but really focuses on the jurisdictions with the biggest markets for electronic products. And there we see offensive litigation as a good choice, and that is Germany, the US and China.
Rolf Claessen: Yes, talking about patent quality is really a hot topic right now, especially in industry and at the EPO, I guess, but that’s a topic for a different hour, probably. But talking about litigation-ready patents, you recently obtained possibly the first ex parte preliminary injunction at a German trade show in recent history, without a protective writ having been filed by the defendant. What does that show about your view on German national courts versus the UPC for this kind of enforcement?
Peter Berg: I mean, first of all, litigation is not an end in itself, and in the markets a semiconductor company like Infineon operates in, a product might implement potentially hundreds or thousands of patents. So litigation itself doesn’t resolve all of that, but it has its place in our strategy execution. You’ll understand that I can’t get into specifics of any of the litigations you hinted at. But enforcement of trademarks, and I think you mentioned a patent case, trademarks and patents at trade fairs has been part of our activities for years, and sometimes you can catch somebody by surprise. It’s all about good preparation. But what I believe is more important is that we also prepare for venues so far less used by Western companies, be it China, et cetera. So being litigation-ready means looking into different venues. The UPC is certainly one of them, but there’s more beyond that. Enforcement for us is not only a German or European measure. I personally believe national courts and the UPC will both have a role to play in the future. There are pros and cons to each, which need to be evaluated case by case. I need to congratulate the UPC, which had a great start, good management, good communication about what they do, and a selection of judges based on quality, not politics. In a little more than three years, they’ve built up a pretty good body of case law. On the downside, some countries are still missing, building a really comprehensive body of case law will take time, and the cost side is still a concern, meaning that not every kind of business case reaches damages high enough to justify it, and there’s a certain risk that the case won’t be decided quickly by the court. In such situations, it might not make sense to go to the UPC. We have, I guess, quite a few companies in the electronics or mechanical engineering field where we don’t validate European patents in dozens of countries, maybe two, three, four, and over time it might be even fewer. So geographically, the difference between US, UPC and national enforcement isn’t that big. That’s why the alternative, and I mentioned this a bit at the beginning regarding the national IP strategy, needs to stay a good alternative. So the possibility to opt out and litigate nationally in lesser business cases remains, from my perspective, important, and we continue to use that as well.
Rolf Claessen: Yes, and also the hurdle for double patenting has been lowered a little, so you can still have national patent rights in parallel with UPC patent rights. That’s also an advantage, probably.
Peter Berg: Yeah, I think that was almost an invitation to say, you know, if you’re not sure whether the unitary patent is your choice, you can do both in parallel. True. But again, all we need to do is achieve our goals with a good cost-benefit ratio, so systematically double patenting is not really the way forward for us.
Rolf Claessen: Right. Yeah, that was a very interesting insight about German national courts versus the UPC. But in fact you’re also litigating across borders, in many different countries, for example the US, Europe, Germany, and other countries, in China maybe. So what does coordinating enforcement across all these different systems simultaneously actually look like from the inside, and was it always the plan to have such complex litigation and enforcement systems, or did it evolve? What’s your take on this?
Peter Berg: Yeah, at Infineon, our legal and patent departments, as we call them, have grown together over the last 25 years, roughly the age of our company, into an organization that doesn’t just have broad general legal or semiconductor application market expertise, for us that’s automotive, consumer goods, industrial and IoT, but is an organization that’s been tested by hundreds of assertions against us and our customers, and by negotiations with operating companies and NPEs. So that comes with experience. If I look now at our organization, not just my own team but legal in general, we have patent and legal teams in all the hotspots, and that’s grown in the last couple of years too. It’s Europe, of course North America, and various countries in Asia, and it’s a fully integrated international organization. We know each other and communicate, it feels like, on at least a weekly basis. Not to forget a good network of outside counsel to execute enforcement wherever strategic needs require it. That’s kind of our promise to management: we don’t shy away from any jurisdiction, if the need is there we can act and set up a team. Perhaps we’ve learned more on the defensive side, which we can now translate into offensive action. And I guess you’re somehow relating your question to a specific litigation against a Chinese competitor, and that’s not a litigation you kind of slide into. You need to plan a few steps ahead. Litigation has become part of our daily life, and the key moment is always, once it’s decided that this is going to happen, to set up a team for the new litigation. It starts to feel like a routine operation. The staffing depends of course on the technical area of the enforcement, the jurisdiction, and the workload of existing attorneys. And the good thing is that once we rotate patent attorneys into a litigation team, it’s great experience for them, that leads to expertise, and since we try not to over-specialize, so that people don’t only do litigation or only do prosecution, that experience from litigation is a great asset when they go back to supporting a certain business unit doing prosecution work. And coming back to your first question, that personal experience also helps in creating litigation-ready patents over time.
Rolf Claessen: Yes, you’ve also acquired a couple of companies, and I have a question about a certain deal, especially the Marvell Brightlane acquisition and the IP due diligence. This $2.5 billion Brightlane deal closed in August 2025 and presumably transferred a substantial patent portfolio in the automotive, let’s say networking, technology field. How much of that big deal is really about buying IP, and how does a deal like that change your daily work in your IP function the day after closing? So once you’d signed the deal, did your daily life change?
Peter Berg: It depends on the size of the deal. A couple of questions in there. Let me start with IP in the semiconductor industry, my industry, and that’s more than patents, trademarks and design rights. Speaking to practitioners and R&D colleagues, IP for them is rather frozen technologies and what we call IP blocks, design blocks which enable fast product designs that you can reuse. And if I take that as a basis, although each acquisition is different, IP plays a very big role because it should enable us to bring new products to market quickly, et cetera. Seldom does Infineon acquire a business because of its patent portfolio. Being a large, established player, our existing patent portfolio should be good enough to move into whatever technical area is of interest, and to make sure incumbent competitors couldn’t easily attack us when entering that field. Now, you mentioned the Marvell acquisition. We call it rather the Marvell automotive Ethernet acquisition. From Marvell’s perspective it was a smaller part of their business, which they sold to Infineon about a year ago. How should I say it, you get the assets but you get relatively little IP. So it’s more that you try to familiarize yourself with the assets and how they fit our business case, et cetera. Of course there is due diligence to get an idea and to make sure that everything that should belong to the business is transparent, but the more important part comes after the acquisition. Once the business is owned by Infineon, all the other functions handle their own areas of responsibility. For us, when it comes to IP rights, it’s about reaching out to the new colleagues, helping them for the first couple of days, but also leaving them alone, because there are so many changes they have to go through, and not being overly pushy. Understanding their current processes and tools, and their view of their own portfolio, is important at that point. So you hold back a little and see what they do and why they do it, sometimes you can learn from their best practices. But there comes a moment when we need to finally decide how to integrate the portfolio, and which of our processes and tools they have to adopt, and the faster you make that decision, the better. Since in the case of Marvell none of the IP staff joined us, the task was to build up a portfolio using the expertise of the senior engineers, get a good operational patent committee running, and develop a plan for which areas of the portfolio are good enough and which need to grow, in line with the growth of the business. It’s now more than a year ago, but that was an interesting time, and I doubt many people listening are aware of it, but a big thank you to everybody involved back in 2025.
Rolf Claessen: From your answer I get that your job involved a lot of listening, basically, to the needs of the teams that joined your company, right?
Peter Berg: At least as much talking as listening. Of course they want to know as well how we do things and what’s expected of them. So first of all it’s about reaching those people and making sure, and this is also a concern, that if everything changes for them, then perhaps the patenting process isn’t the most important thing. Product development is key, and making sure there’s no interruption so they can keep their timelines, et cetera. So being very mindful of that setting. But you’re right, it’s not just about telling them, it’s about listening to them and finding the right moment to switch.
Rolf Claessen: Right, I have a very different question now, about NPEs, non-practicing entities, and exposure. I think some NPEs acquired patent families that trace back to Cypress, just before you bought it, or around the time of your acquisition. Are these patents, held by these NPEs, now a problem for Infineon?
Peter Berg: That would be it, right? Actually, no, let me give some context first. Companies in distress, or with an overly large patent portfolio for their business, sometimes sell patents at a certain point in their history. Regarding Cypress Semiconductor, that happened around 2016, after they merged with a company called Spansion and ended up with a large combined portfolio they didn’t need. At that point Cypress teamed up with an NPE organization called IP Value and sold them around 2,000 patents, that’s public knowledge, and only a few years later Infineon acquired Cypress. So that was done by Cypress before it became an Infineon company. But good practice is, if you sell a patent, you retain a license for your own business, so in that sense I don’t feel any exposure from those patents. But of course this touches on the general topic of exposure to NPE enforcement, which is a concern in the electronics industry. Realistically, hundreds is perhaps too much, but many dozens of new cases a month, often against our customers or the wider ecosystem. But since it involves technology implemented in our products, even if the enforcement doesn’t target semiconductor players directly, we need to support our customers, and that is a kind of a load we need to help carry. But these are typically patents that somebody else sold to an NPE. You were also asking whether acquiring businesses brings new opportunities as well as new risk. I think that’s natural, and we shouldn’t shy away from that kind of risk. If we, like any other company, go for the big, high-margin, fast-growing businesses, the stakes are high in those areas, and you can’t complain if these also turn out to be litigious marketplaces, because many people want to be there. Around this time of year, since it’s Oktoberfest season here in Munich, many IP practitioners from around the world gather for meetings and share their view on the world. Everybody talks about AI, and NPEs try to acquire whatever patents are on the market that could be the basis of stronger or weaker infringement actions against that part of the industry. From an industry perspective, this consumes a lot of resources and doesn’t really help accelerate innovation in our space.
Rolf Claessen: Good that you have a solution for the patent families that were acquired before you acquired Cypress. And now, turning to a very different topic, cryptography. You’re also working on quantum cryptography and post-quantum cryptography, a difficult word, and you, Infineon, were the first to obtain a certification, a really high certification in post-quantum cryptography, the so-called CC EAL6 certification, a very high certification in cryptography for our listeners, in December 2024. Now this field of technology is heading towards standardization. How patent-dense is Infineon’s patent stack in this field, and how are you thinking about the potential standard-essentiality of this new post-quantum cryptography technology, where maybe the American standards from the NIST institute become the infrastructure, or the standard?
Peter Berg: It’s a big field with different components. We take the quantum challenge seriously at Infineon, but there are two elements to it. You spoke more about cryptography, but for us, as a semiconductor player, on one hand we want to enable quantum computing with our own chipsets, and we support two different technology streams there, it’s not just development, it’s already a real business. On the other hand, we need to educate and enable customers in the application fields we serve to prepare for that quantum day, the day quantum computing becomes available, and not only to the good guys. You need to think about this now, because it might be just three, four, five years away, you don’t know for sure. It means investing in infrastructure able to handle post-quantum cryptography and security in communications, because you need certain computing power and different ways of handling cryptography algorithms compared to today. Today’s approaches won’t be enough, you need better ones, and you mentioned one at the beginning, which Infineon has proposed. That’s not easy. If you invest in a core today, you’re investing in something like a power station, which stays connected to the internet for a long time, so you need infrastructure robust enough to handle post-quantum cryptography. Regarding the patent stack question, yes, certainly there are several patents in this field owned by Infineon, but also by others. In general, I believe, both in semiconductors and in security more broadly, this tends toward royalty-free licensing, and standard setting has in the past been marked by the avoidance of the big patent clusters we saw building up in cellular communication, from 2G through 5G. I don’t see that happening in the post-quantum cryptography field, but who knows, so we prepare for whatever scenario comes.
Rolf Claessen: Let’s see if the Infineon patents end up in a big pool or something later on, and you get all these license fees.
Peter Berg: I wouldn’t mind, yeah.
Rolf Claessen: Let’s see. Right, now turning to another topic, maybe, for example US colleagues ask me a lot about the German employee invention law. It’s very different from other countries, especially the US. Do you see the German employee invention law rather as an opportunity or a burden for Germany’s innovation ecosystem?
Peter Berg: As IP professionals in larger corporations in Germany, we’re so used to that law that we hardly challenge its usefulness. To your question, though, with more than 30 years of experience, I’d say that 99% of all inventions are made by engineers in R&D as part of their regular job, nothing extra on top, so they don’t need an extra motivation for it. And we see it in other countries too, where that kind of law doesn’t exist, and people are just as innovative and just as ready to share their inventions with us as an IP organization, with or without the law. So it doesn’t seem to fulfill the role some see as a competitive edge for Germany, and because of that inventor law, people just end up being more cautious, or more descriptive, about their work results. There are more reasons why I believe this is obsolete. Invention does not equal innovation. There are many other colleagues in a company, in procurement, production, quality management, et cetera, and all of them contribute to a product becoming a bestseller. It’s not a single person, and it’s not just one team’s result, and somehow it doesn’t feel fair that the inventor gets an additional bonus and the others don’t. In any case we’d give our top engineers a premium anyway, and we reward inventors in all other countries, with the law or without it, without any worldwide mandate for that kind of remuneration. So from a corporate perspective we don’t need a law to help us work out the benefits and share them with our top inventors. The law is a bureaucratic nightmare. It needs to be abandoned, or at least radically simplified. In smaller organizations, I guess it’s often just ignored or badly implemented. Believe me, every company we’ve acquired with operations in Germany has left us a bit of a heritage to clean up.
Rolf Claessen: Yeah, I understand. Now for a different topic, AI, the use of AI. We as patent attorneys talk about this a lot, it’s a big topic, how to use AI, whether to use AI, and how to use AI in law firms. But can you tell us about the use of AI in the operations of your team?
Peter Berg: Recently we discussed this and agreed on kind of three layers to it. First, good use of established AI tools. AI, in that sense, isn’t something that started three years ago with ChatGPT. It began with search, patent search, then translation, at least between the major languages like German and English, which most of my team masters, and then, I’d say about two years ago, drafting and replies to office actions. So there are established tools, and as with every tool, you need to use it repeatedly, at a certain volume, to really benefit from it. We try to work with the best of these established tools, driving wider adoption within the team and partnering with our law firms, since a substantial part of the legal work is done by our outside counsel. So this is a bit of a joint exercise. Second, there are constantly new tools coming up, which we try to test. There are many, so the time we have available to look into them is the limiting factor. I’d like to test more, because there might be a new frontrunner coming up that we should definitely try ourselves. But last, and certainly not least, we try to implement AI into everyday operations, into the office environment itself. The company made a good decision in spring to allow wide adoption of AI-specific tools in a secure environment, and that has opened up a lot of opportunities for everybody, paralegals and attorneys alike, and now it’s about fostering an open exchange on what’s possible and what’s not. And finally, since Infineon, like most corporations, doesn’t do everything in-house, there’s the question of what the benefits are that we can plan around, so that we get better quality. If the quality of the AI results isn’t as good as the attorney’s results before, then we shouldn’t use it, or we’d spend so much time cleaning it up afterwards that nobody could tell the difference. Second, we can now do things that weren’t possible before, because they were too tedious or took too long, or we get faster turnaround times, so we can respond more quickly to standardization proposals, what used to take many days we can now do in a few days, while still trusting the quality of the output. And only then comes what’s often discussed as efficiency gains, and the question that will probably be asked next year is how we split the pie: if both we and outside counsel benefit from using AI, what do we do with those benefits, how much stays with outside counsel, and how much should also benefit my budget?
Rolf Claessen: But I clearly see the advantages of using AI, I’m using it myself, especially for cases like oppositions, where in earlier times you had to read through some 30 papers, patents and books, and now you can just ask the AI where you find a certain feature across those 30 documents. So it’s really useful in a lot of cases. Now my last question to you, and maybe the most important one, what do you think are the three most important messages you want to convey to our listeners, who are mostly IP professionals, both in-house and in law firms?
Peter Berg: Do you want me to repeat things I said before, or can I think freely, in general? Free thinking, of course. Okay. Many of the things we spoke about now were about what to do next, and how to execute certain things, how to prepare. I believe that if you think about IP strategy, you think about it from the end: what do I need to assert, against whom, for what purpose, before building a portfolio of IP rights. So it’s not just about the deadlines you have today and tomorrow, which you somehow have to get through, but about taking a step back and thinking, what should this be good for in 10 or 20 years’ time. If you do that, it helps you get to litigation-grade patents and litigation readiness. We’re all busy, and there are so many things we need to do today and tomorrow, so it’s easily forgotten to look a little further down the road. So I’d say, think about a multi-year plan to achieve your goals, and there are hardly any moments, unless perhaps you’re one of the big AI platforms with unlimited resources, where that isn’t true. So plan for multiple years, but with a good cost-benefit ratio in mind. And I can’t really avoid mentioning AI here. It’s having a major impact on our operations. We’ve talked about it, we’ve tested it, but ramping it up is a different matter, and I think next year will be decisive. That’s really the full value chain, from interacting with our inventors to get better quality ideas, all the way to claim charting and negotiating, the bread-and-butter activities of patent attorneys, drafting office action replies is of course part of that too. I’m really keen to see that happen, and I’m trying to keep my team ahead of the wave. And I can only encourage everybody in our profession, if you don’t yet have a contact, team up with friends or colleagues in the profession, use the various associations that exist in our profession to network and discuss. The worst thing is to miss the train, and it takes time, this isn’t something you become good at overnight, so it needs time to train, and it’s good to start now.
Rolf Claessen: Yes, that’s a very good point, and closing where we began, with the VPP, exchanging ideas among colleagues really is key, I think, important. Thank you very much for being on IP Fridays, on our podcast. That was really interesting, and I think our listeners can learn a lot from this interview. Thank you very much.
Peter Berg: Don’t mention it, it was a pleasure talking to you, and for me it was also the first time doing this kind of podcast. Thank you.
Rolf Claessen: Thank youDupe Culture Is a Legal Problem Now: What Caitlin Byczko Taught Us About Trade Dress, TikTok, and the Limits of Brand Enforcement – IP Fridays Podcast – Episode 178
28/08/2026 | 24 minI am Rolf Claessen and my co-host Ken Suzan and I are welcoming you to episode 178 of our podcast IP Fridays! Today’s interview guest is Caitlin Byczko, who is partner with Marnes & Thornburg in their IP team. Ken is discussing dupe culture with her.
Here is the profile of Caitlin Byczko https://btlaw.com/en/people/caitlin-byczko
But before we launch into this very interesting interview, I have some news for you:
On August 10th, 2026, Navitas Semiconductor filed suit against Renesas Electronics in the Eastern District of Texas, accusing Renesas of infringing four US patents on gallium nitride semiconductor technology through its SuperGaN product lines. The filing follows a countersuit Renesas brought on July 22nd, 2026, accusing Navitas and two of its employees of misappropriating trade secrets. It shows how patent disputes and trade secret claims between competitors are increasingly being fought on multiple fronts at once, and often as tit for tat.
It also emerged on August 12th, 2026, that an EPO Board of Appeal had dismissed an appeal by Atlas Global Technologies and ruled that its WiFi patent, EP 3 353 901, case T 1230/25, could not be maintained in any form at all, even though the original opponents, TP-Link and Vantiva, had already withdrawn their oppositions. That knocked out the basis for several parallel infringement suits at the Unified Patent Court, which were then withdrawn. For suppliers and implementers, the takeaway is that fighting a patent held by a non-practising entity can still be worth it, even once the original opponent has thrown in the towel.
On August 10th, 2026, the Unified Patent Court in The Hague fully revoked Maxell’s patent EP 2 061 230, covering technology for handing off content to a second device, and at the same time dismissed Maxell’s infringement claim against several Samsung entities, in cases UPC_CFI_251/2025 and UPC_CFI_769/2025. The judges found the patent to be nothing more than an obvious combination of routine adaptations, with no additional technical effect.
And now – let’s hear the interview with Ken and Caitlin!
A dupe used to be a quiet, slow thing. You’d stand in the cereal aisle, notice the generic box next to the name brand, buy it, tell a friend. Word spread over months.
That world is gone. On this episode of IP Fridays, Ken Suzan sat down with Caitlin Byczko, partner at Barnes & Thornburg LLP in Indianapolis, to talk about what’s replaced it: a TikTok-driven economy where a single video can sell out a dupe product within hours, sometimes before the original brand’s own team even knows it exists. Byczko litigates and prosecutes trademarks across retail, fashion, luxury goods, technology, and pharmaceuticals, and she’s watched dupe culture evolve from a marketing footnote into one of the more active battlegrounds in trademark law.
Here’s what she told us, and why it matters even if your brand has never heard the word “dupe” used about it.
Counterfeit and Dupe Are Not the Same Thing, Legally
Byczko opened with what she called the most important distinction in this entire conversation: the difference between a counterfeit and a dupe.
A counterfeit uses someone else’s actual trademark. Think of a fake Chanel bag stamped with the interlocking C’s, or a fake Louis Vuitton logo. That’s straightforward infringement, and above certain thresholds, a federal crime.
A dupe is different. It mimics the look, feel, or performance of a product without using the name or the logo at all. Elf Cosmetics, Zara, Costco’s Kirkland brand, and Quince have all built parts of their business on exactly this model. No one is pretending to be Chanel. They’re offering something that looks and performs similarly, at a fraction of the price, under their own name.
Media and social media use “dupe” and “counterfeit” interchangeably. Legally, that’s sloppy, and it matters, because the two categories trigger completely different legal analyses.
If There’s No Logo, What Are Brands Actually Suing Over?
This is where trade dress comes in. Trade dress protects the overall look and feel of a product: packaging, color combinations, shape, label design. Byczko pointed out that most of us interact with trade-dress-protected products every day without realizing it.
The test is likelihood of confusion. Courts look at how similar the products actually look, how sophisticated the shoppers are, and whether there’s real evidence that people were confused.
Byczko flagged one case as a genuine roadmap for this area: Van Leeuwen v. Rebel Creamery, an ice cream trade dress dispute that came out of the Eastern District of New York. In her view, the strength of that case came down to how precisely the brand defined its trade dress for the packaging. That precision, she said, did a lot of the work toward the outcome.
She’s also watching Lululemon v. Costco, which she expects to be significant partly because it doesn’t rely on trademark and trade dress alone. Byczko noted that brands are increasingly stacking causes of action together: trademark, patent, false advertising, all pointing at the same product. And she’s tracking Sol de Janeiro v. Macau Beauty, a case she finds notable because it pulls in influencer content and testimonials as evidence, not just packaging and trade dress claims. Macau Beauty, she noted, has already been sued multiple times across different jurisdictions.
A note for readers outside the US: trade dress as a distinct doctrine doesn’t exist as such in Germany. The closest tools here are the three-dimensional trademark and, more practically, the wettbewerbsrechtlicher Nachahmungsschutz under Section 4 No. 3 of the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG). That provision protects product shape, packaging, and get-up against imitation when the original has wettbewerbliche Eigenart, competitive distinctiveness, and the copy creates avoidable confusion about origin, unfairly exploits the original’s reputation, or was built on dishonestly obtained know-how. It’s a narrower, more fact-specific tool than US trade dress, but the underlying logic Byczko describes, define your product’s distinctive features early and precisely, applies just as much on this side of the Atlantic.
Why the Evidence Problem Changed Everything
Ken asked what’s actually driving the current wave of disputes, and Byczko’s answer was simple: evidence.
Ten or twenty years ago, if you sent a cease-and-desist letter or went to trial, you had almost nothing concrete to show about how consumers actually perceived two products. Now you have TikTok comment sections, influencer testimonials, and entire genres of “dupe content” documenting exactly what shoppers think, in their own words, in real time.
In the Sol de Janeiro case, Byczko noted that part of the complaint isn’t just about packaging and trade dress. It’s about what influencers said, what claims they made, and what that content reveals about actual consumer confusion or the absence of it. That’s evidence litigators simply didn’t have access to a decade ago, and it cuts both ways: it can prove confusion, or it can just as easily prove there wasn’t any.
Why Dupes Took Off: Economics, Status, and a Generational Shift
Byczko was careful to frame this part as her personal read, not a sociologist’s conclusion, but it’s a read shaped by watching these disputes up close.
Part of it is straightforward economics. Gen Z is shopping under real affordability pressure, and dupes let them participate in trend cycles without the price tag. Byczko cited a projected $12.6 trillion in Gen Z spending power by 2030, a generation too significant for brands to write off.
The other part is cultural. A generation ago, owning a visible logo was the status symbol. Now, for a lot of younger shoppers, being the savvy one, the person who finds the dupe first and tells their followers about it, carries its own status. It’s less “I have the real thing” and more “I outsmarted the markup.” Byczko also pointed to growing public skepticism toward paying five or ten times more for a product purely because of the name on the packaging, particularly in beauty and fashion.
The PR Trap: When Enforcement Backfires
One of the sharpest points in the conversation was about what happens after a brand decides to enforce. Suing over a dupe can read very differently in public than it does in a courtroom.
Byczko put it directly: going after a dupe can easily look, to the public, like a big corporation coming down on a small competitor, or worse, on its own customers, the same people who made the original brand aspirational in the first place. She’s seen this dynamic play out repeatedly in high-profile cases.
Her advice: treat enforcement as a communication strategy, not just a legal one. Sometimes the smarter move isn’t a lawsuit at all. It’s a quieter cease-and-desist letter, a takedown request, or doubling down on marketing that explains what actually makes the original worth the price. Charlotte Tilbury has leaned hard into this approach, building campaigns around the idea that the original simply can’t be remade. Olaplex ran a similar play with its “OlaDupe” campaign. Legal and marketing, Byczko said, have to work together on this, not in sequence.
What Brands Should Actually Do
Byczko laid out three practical layers, all before litigation ever enters the picture.
First: register your trademarks, and where a product design is genuinely distinctive, pursue trade dress or design patent protection early, before a dupe exists and before you know whether the product will even take off. That timing problem is real. Brands rarely know in advance which product will become the one worth copying. Her advice was to look at long-standing anchor products, the ones that have quietly carried a brand identity for years, and ask whether they’re actually protected.
Second: monitor. A large share of dupe disputes start on social media, not in a courtroom. That means someone needs to be watching hashtags and influencer content, not just from direct competitors, but from adjacent or even unrelated brands that could end up duping a product without anyone noticing until it’s already trending.
Third, and the one Byczko clearly considers most underused: consumer education and brand storytelling. “This is the original” is a weak pitch on its own in a market flooded with cheap alternatives. What works better is explaining, specifically, what makes a product different: its formulation, its sourcing, its performance, its longevity. Give people a real reason to pay more, not just a claim to authenticity.
Where This Goes Next
Byczko doesn’t think dupe culture is a passing trend. Her expectation is closer to “there will eventually be a dupe of everything,” and she’s watching an interesting generational pattern where teenage shoppers are teaching their mothers about dupes, who are in turn teaching their own mothers.
On the legal side, she expects more clarity as cases like Van Leeuwen work their way through the system, giving brands a clearer formula for how to define and defend trade dress. On the brand side, she expects less reliance on litigation as the primary weapon and more investment in what’s genuinely hard to copy: real innovation, ingredient transparency, and storytelling that a dupe simply can’t replicate.
One data point she raised stuck with us: search interest in the word “craftsmanship” is at its highest point in twenty years. After years of leaning into dupe culture, there are signs some consumers are swinging back toward wanting the original, the real ingredient, the real technique, the thing that can’t be copied to the same quality.
For brands sitting on distinctive packaging, a signature shape, or a product identity they’ve never formally registered, that’s less a trend forecast than a to-do list.
Here is the full transcript:
Ken Suzan: Thank you, Ralf. Our guest today on the IP Friday’s podcast is Caitlin Byczko. Caitlin is a partner with Barnes and Thornburg LLP and is based in Indianapolis, Indiana. Caitlin crafts and defends global brand strategies, protecting intellectual property assets with creative solutions and highly tactical advocacy. She excels in trademark prosecution and litigation before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board and federal district courts, safeguarding trademarks and digital properties for businesses of all sizes and at every stage of the business life cycle. From startups to Fortune 500 companies, Caitlin manages clients’ intellectual property needs across diverse industries. Her experience spans retail, fashion, luxury goods, sports, technology, agriculture, venture capital and pharmaceuticals. Beyond trademark law, Caitlin brings valuable insights from her law school experience with the National Collegiate Athletic Association, NCAA, and her previous work serving in a technology company’s in-house legal department. Her tenacious nature and clever problem-solving skills shine through in complex matters, earning praise from clients and colleagues alike. Caitlin is co-author of “Dupe Culture Meets the Courtroom,” published in Global Cosmetic Industry on March 16, 2026. Welcome, Caitlin, to the IP Friday’s podcast.
Caitlin Byczko: Hi, Ken. Thank you so much. I’m very honored to be here.
Ken Suzan: Yeah, so Caitlin, today we’re talking about dupe culture, a topic that is rapidly becoming front for many brands around the world. What’s the actual difference between a dupe and a counterfeit?
Caitlin Byczko: That is one of my favorite questions. This is the most important distinction to draw when we are talking legally about dupes because the difference, because media and social media often use the words interchangeably and legally they’re very different. A counterfeit is a product that uses someone else’s actual trademark. We often think of a fake Chanel bag with interlocking C’s or a fake Louis Vuitton. It’s relatively straightforward trademark infringement and generally above certain thresholds is a federal crime. A dupe, by contrast, is a product that mimics the look, feel, or performance product without actually using the name or logo. We often think of it in the beauty products, in the fashion space, some brands like Elf Cosmetics, which was in the article you just mentioned, Zara, Costco’s Kirkland brand, Quince, who are all very well known in the dupe space.
Ken Suzan: What has led to the rise of dupe culture? I’m reading about it virtually every day.
Caitlin Byczko: I feel very strongly about this and I’m always talking about it in my legal and non-legal worlds. It’s a very interesting societal change that I think we’ve seen over the past year. I am a lawyer, I am not a marketer, I am not a sociologist, but in my opinion, social media and influencer culture specifically has really created the kind of rise in dupes that we see today. I don’t think we can talk about modern dupe culture without talking about TikTok specifically. Dupe content is its own genre, essentially on TikTok and on Instagram. There’s a whole vocabulary that people are dupe influencers, where their whole product, everything that they’re doing and selling, all of the content they’re making is dupe related. What’s really changed is the speed, I think, around when other products or when a dupe product comes out, how it can be marketed and how people can find out about it. The speed of commerce itself has increased wildly as a result, in part because of social media. A product used to take months to build a reputation as a good alternative. When we think about things, generic cereal is one thing that I have been talking about with my parents with respect to dupe culture. It was one of the things that there used to be, you would go to the store and there would be the cereal, the name brand cereal, and then there would be the generic version of the cereal, which was usually less expensive. That in a way was a dupe. It took a long time. Your friends knew about the dupe cereal and then you knew about the dupe cereal. Then it all got around. Now a single video can send a dupe product sold out within days, within hours sometimes. Oftentimes, a brand’s own team doesn’t even know about the dupe until it’s already been wildly out. Part of it becomes this legal issue when there are claims coming around the dupe. In the Sol de Janeiro case against Macau Beauty, part of the complaint isn’t just about the trade dress and the packaging, which I think we’ll talk about. It’s about the influencer content and the testimonials and what people are saying about the dupes. There’s so much evidence now and there’s so much content and there’s so much out there regarding dupes on social media, on TikTok, and in other places.
Ken Suzan: Yeah, and it’s an ever-evolving story. Every day there’s new social media content, more evidence for a potential gain, right?
Caitlin Byczko: Absolutely.
Ken Suzan: So if dupes aren’t using a particular brand name, how are companies suing over them at all?
Caitlin Byczko: So this is really where trade dress comes in, and trade dress, as most of us know, has been around for a long time. There are a lot of very well-known things that you probably see or use every day that you don’t know are protected by trade dress, but they are. And the trade dress protects the overall kind of look and feel of a product. So if you think about things like packaging, color combinations, shape, label design, when that becomes distinctive enough, right? When consumers see that and kind of immediately understand it has the secondary meaning related to the brand owner, then it can become a protectable trademark. And so the test for trademark infringement is likelihood of confusion. And courts will look at the factors of how similar the products actually look, how sophisticated the shoppers are, whether there’s evidence that people were actually confused. I think one of the big cases in the trade dress space that came out since you and I discussed originally, Ken, is the Van Leeuwen versus Rebel Creamery ice cream case. And so for any of those interested, it’s a very interesting opinion. It just came out of the Eastern District of New York. I think that really helps people, brands specifically, kind of provide a roadmap with respect to how to define a trade dress. I think they did an excellent job there defining what the trade dress was for the packaging. And I think that that had a lot to do with the success.
Ken Suzan: Yes.
Ken Suzan: Why do you think younger consumers gravitate towards dupes so much more than past generations did?
Caitlin Byczko: I think there are a few things that are kind of top of each other. The obvious one is economics. I think younger consumers, especially Gen Z, they’re shopping in an environment where there’s affordability pressure. And I think that dupes let them participate in certain trend cycles without the price tag. Gen Z is a significant demographic behind the growth of dupes. And they have a predicted spending power we saw recently, $12.6 trillion by 2030.
Ken Suzan: Wow. That’s incredible.
Caitlin Byczko: I think it is really also coupled with more of what I would say is a cultural shift. Again, I am a lawyer and this is just my opinion. But what feels aspirational is really changing, I think. And a generation ago, we saw in the fashion world, there was a really big, people really liked logos. Having a logo, owning a logo was the point. And now for a lot of younger shoppers or even more savvy shoppers, actually being a savvy shopper is the status symbol itself. So for a lot of creators, finding the dupe before anyone else or being the one who tells your followers about the dupe really has its own, and it’s less “I have this real thing” and more, “oh, I outsmarted the markup.” And I think it’s that kind of value. I think younger consumers are more publicly skeptical of the idea that something is worth five or ten times more just because of the name on the packaging. And I think that that becomes the case particularly in beauty and then clothing as well. And so I think it’s coupled with the question of craftsmanship and all of these different things. Like we can’t view anything in a vacuum, which is why I could talk for 500 years about this topic.
Ken Suzan: Yeah, definitely. Now brands obviously want to protect themselves. That’s an important thing. But going after a dupe can backfire publicly, particularly on the internet. Can you comment on this possibility and what should brands do?
Caitlin Byczko: Sure. I think the biggest thing is what you just said. So I think there’s the legal component. And when we’re assessing this for one of our brand clients, I think we cannot review one without the other. So I think you have to say, do we have this claim? Do we have a protectable trade dress or a look and feel claim? And what is the potential backlash in the public? I think it is also a joint PR concern, because what we see is suing over a dupe can very easily read to the public as, oh, this big brand or big corporation is coming down on a small competitor or on its own customers that made the original brand aspirational. I think that we see this in a lot of the big cases that are out right now. So brands, I think, can start to think about enforcement as a communication strategy first, because sometimes the smarter play isn’t necessarily filing a lawsuit. It’s kind of a quieter cease and desist, a takedown request, or separately, it might be really doubling down on the craftsmanship or on a marketing side of what makes the product worth the price. I think Charlotte Tilbury is a great example of this, who’s really leaned into this kind of “can’t be duped” or “you can’t remake the original” with respect to some of their really core products. And so I think people really need to, or brands really need to, assess: one, how can we define what it is that’s being duped? And again, that’s where I think that Van Leeuwen case, I think, will be really interesting over the next few years, with respect to kind of providing this roadmap to help people say, here is a way that we can try to really define what the trade dress is and then be able to protect it and be able to enforce it.
Ken Suzan: Caitlin, are there cases right now, I know we just talked about the Van Leeuwen case, but are there cases right now that you think will actually set the tone for how this area of law develops?
Caitlin Byczko: Absolutely. And I think some of the cases probably are even in the works, they’re not even filed yet, which is probably very exciting to us as trademark nerds. I do think the Lululemon versus Costco case will be a big one. It’s not just trademarks and trade dress, as many of them are not. I think a lot of times we see in these cases brands are very smartly using kind of all of the different types of causes of action that they bring: trademark, patent, false advertising, a lot of different things. And so I think that that one is definitely certainly one to watch kind of in the fashion space. And then the Sol de Janeiro versus Macau Beauty. Macau Beauty has been sued multiple times, I think, in various jurisdictions. And so I think part of that one is very interesting to me because I think it’s this, it loops not only trademark protection, but also it brings in false advertising, it brings in influencers, it brings in all of these different things. And so I think, like we had talked about previously, nothing is really viewed in a vacuum. And I think for all of these cases, one really important thing, maybe that we didn’t necessarily have access to 10 years ago, or certainly 20 years ago, is this like just ripe amount of evidence of potential confusion or potential non-confusion. When we go on social media and look at all of these things, and then read the comments and all of this different data that’s out there, it’s fascinating, because if you’re in trial, or if you’re going to trial, you’re sending a cease and desist letter, like there is evidence of what the consumers think right here in front of you, right? And the weight of that evidence obviously depends on what it is. But it’s fascinating the way that you can very quickly identify, you know, is there confusion? Is there not confusion, in a way that you likely could never have even thought to consider 10 to 20 years ago?
Ken Suzan: Now beyond litigation, what should brands actually be doing to protect themselves in a dupe-driven market?
Caitlin Byczko: I think one of the best things that we can do, right, is starting to register the trademarks. I think that’s an obvious one. And really start to consider where the product is genuinely distinctive. And so if it is genuinely distinctive, pursuing a trade dress or a design patent early, before a dupe exists, before anything happens. And I know that can be difficult, because oftentimes brands don’t know for sure what’s going to take off and what’s not. It can also be a surprise. But I think it’s really pushing brands that when you are innovating and when you are doing something that is truly unique and truly distinctive, or when you’re looking back on your brand assets and saying, this thing has been an anchor brand asset for 10 years, you know, have we sought trade dress protection? Is there a way that we can do that? The second layer really is monitoring, in my mind, because a lot of dupe disputes do start on social media. And I think it is important to have people within a company, if you have a product that you’re really keeping an eye on, or that you’re concerned about being duped or causing confusion, having someone who is keeping eyes on hashtags and influencer content and all of these various things. You know, we’re not watching just your direct competitors, we’re watching other completely different brands, or kind of made-up brands even, who could be duping the product. And then I think the third thing that I see as very important is this kind of consumer education and brand storytelling, which is when we kind of get outside of the purely legal side of it. And, you know, legal and marketing and brand and social kind of all need to work together, right? I think if the only pitch to consumers is “this is the original,” it kind of becomes a weak argument in a market where there are cheap alternatives everywhere. But I think the brands that really explain what actually makes their product different, in its formulation, its sourcing, its performance, its longevity, it really gives people a real reason to say, I want to pay more for this brand because of XYZ, you know, the technology or whatever that is. Charlotte Tilbury is one that I had mentioned. I know Olaplex kind of had a big campaign around “OlaDupe” is what they called it. So I think really unique and interesting marketing also assists with that.
Ken Suzan: Caitlin, where do you see dupe culture heading? Is this a trend that plateaus or does it fundamentally change how brands operate?
Caitlin Byczko: I think dupe culture itself is here to stay. I mean, I think we are only getting into a world where there is truly going to be a dupe of everything. And it’s not good or bad necessarily. I think it is just where we are in life. And I think, you know, things serve different purposes. And it all depends a lot on how the younger consumers shop. And it’s also changing how older consumers shop. You know, I’ve read a lot about teenage girls teaching their moms about dupes, who are then teaching their grandmothers about dupes, right? So on the legal side, I think we will get clarity eventually. I think right around, you know, all like all of these things, which seem so complex, and we’ll never know the answer. You know, five [years] from now, we will probably have certainly more clarity, because a lot of these cases will move forward. You know, the Van Leeuwen one, which I’ve now talked about multiple times, but I just obviously think it’s very fascinating. I think that that’s one where you have a roadmap, right? And it may be contested, or, you know, everything is very fact-specific in the trademark world. But I think it will open the door to allow people one more aggressive brand enforcement. But it will give people a roadmap proactively to kind of say, if we follow this formula for our trade dress, or, you know, defining our trade dress, then, you know, we have something we can potentially protect. And then I think on the brand side, we’ll likely see less reliance on litigation as the primary weapon and more investment in things that are actually, you know, difficult to dupe: innovation, ingredient transparency, marketing, genuinely interesting brand storytelling is something that we’ve seen. I read this past week that searches for craftsmanship, just like generally the word craftsmanship, and kind of products with craftsmanship, is at an all-time high, than it’s been in like the past 20 years. And so it’s interesting, right, that we have gone from this kind of luxury item or high craftsmanship to this dupe culture that we are in now. But there is some potential shift where people are saying, you know, now, I’ve seen all of this and I have all of these options, but now actually what I do care about is the original, right, the innovation or the ingredient transparency or all of those things that can’t necessarily be copied to the same quality. So it’s why it will just provide us with endless topic of discussion, because I think it will only just keep changing forever.
Ken Suzan: That’s right. Caitlin, I want to thank you for spending time with us on the IP Friday’s podcast. This has been very insightful, and I’m sure we’ll be talking about this issue in the months and years to come.
Caitlin Byczko: Thank you so much, Ken. I really appreciate it.
Ken Suzan: Thank you.Long-Arm Jurisdiction in Europe – Interview With the Mastermind Behind the BSH v. Electrolux Decision of the ECJ Dr. Ernst-Peter Heilein – His View on Follow-Up Cases Like Fujifilm, Regeneron, and Onesta – IP Fridays – Episode 177
31/07/2026 | 38 minI am Rolf Claessen and my co-host Ken Suzan and I are welcoming you to episode 177 of our podcast IP Fridays! Today’s interview guest is Dr. Ernst-Peter Heilein, who is a German and European patent attorney, the founder of HEILEIN IP LAW, and a long-time IP leader at BSH Home Appliances. He is the mastermind behind the BSH v. Electrolux decision of the European Court of Justice about long-arm jurisdiction in Europe that has the whole patent world stirring in Europe at the moment!
But before we jump into this fascinating interview, I have news for you!
Emboline v. AorticLab (UPC Court of Appeal)
The UPC Court of Appeal has clarified for the first time how a conditional revocation counterclaim should be handled, in a dispute over Emboline’s embolic protection patent EP 2 129 425 against AorticLab. A defendant can validly make its revocation counterclaim conditional on infringement being found first, meaning no ruling on the counterclaim is needed if the infringement claim fails, as the Munich Local Division had held. The Court of Appeal also closed a related gap: if the claimant appeals a non-infringement finding, the counterclaimant may conditionally appeal the unresolved counterclaim too. AorticLab missed its own appeal deadline and can now at best seek re-establishment of rights, while Emboline has already appealed the non-infringement finding.
FujiFilm v. Kodak (UPC Court of Appeal)
Following the closely watched long-arm jurisdiction ruling of June 2, the UPC Court of Appeal, chaired by Rian Kalden, has now granted FujiFilm an injunction against Kodak in a second proceeding. The Court upheld the limited printing plate patent and found that Kodak’s Sonora XTRA 3 plate infringes it. Kodak can no longer sell or use that plate in Germany.
OpenAI v. EUIPO (General Court of the EU, T-555/25)
The General Court’s Eighth Chamber dismissed OpenAI’s action against the EUIPO decision to partially cancel the OPENAI trademark. The partial refusal for classes 9, 42, and 45 rests decisively on Article 7(1)(c) EUTMR, the descriptiveness ground. For a significant part of the English-speaking public, “OPENAI” directly conveys that the goods or services are provided using freely accessible artificial intelligence.
Dental Monitoring v. Align Technology (CAFC)
On July 7, 2026, the Federal Circuit confirmed that AI and deep-learning patent claims covering dental image analysis are not patent-eligible under Section 101. Simply training a “deep learning device” on a specific dataset does not amount to a patent-eligible technical solution.
Publisher v. Google (Munich I Regional Court)
The Munich I Regional Court issued a preliminary injunction barring Google from spreading false factual claims about a publishing company in its AI Overviews. A search query combining the company’s name with the German term for “fraud scheme” had triggered an AI-generated summary containing entirely fabricated accusations of subscription traps.
KPN v. Oppo (Federal Court of Justice, X ZR 103/24)
On July 1, the Federal Court of Justice dismissed KPN’s appeal against the revocation of a central claim of its LTE patent EP 2 291 033. Oppo had successfully challenged the claim, leaving KPN’s infringement action against Oppo’s German distribution entity without a legal basis for now.
BSH v. Electrolux: What the ECJ Ruling Means for Your Company’s Patent Enforcement Strategy
A vacuum cleaner from 2001 has reshaped the European patent landscape. That sounds like an overstatement. It isn’t. For IP Fridays, I spoke with Dr. Ernst-Peter Heilein, founder of HEILEIN IP LAW and long-time Senior IP Leader at BSH Home Appliances. He guided the case BSH v. Electrolux from its first strategic idea all the way to the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Justice, a case that earned the 2025 Managing IP Award as “Europe Impact Case of the Year.”
For managing directors, IP heads, and R&D leaders at German Mittelstand companies, this case is not a legal footnote. It changes where you can enforce your patents, and it changes where you yourself can be sued if your company operates across several European markets. That is what this article is about.
Background: How a Patent Dispute Became an ECJ Case
The invention dates back to 2001 and concerns a new vacuum cleaner technology. In 2006, BSH identified what it believed was an unauthorized use of that invention and contacted Electrolux to clarify the situation. The European patent was granted in 2009 and validated in a number of European countries. Nobody, Heilein says, could have imagined at the time that this matter would eventually reach the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Justice almost twenty years later.
In late 2018, BSH successfully defended the patent through opposition and appeal proceedings before the European Patent Office. In 2019, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf found that certain Electrolux vacuum cleaner models infringed the patent. A classic milestone win, the kind that occurs regularly in patent practice. Except the patent had been validated in many countries. Winning in Germany did not solve the enforcement problem everywhere else.
Heilein describes the starting point in very concrete terms: how do you enforce a patent that exists in many countries without filing a separate lawsuit in every single one? And how do you prevent claims from becoming time-barred while you work that out? Running parallel proceedings in multiple countries is not just legally complex. It consumes time, personnel, and money that a mid-sized company rarely has in that quantity to spare.
This is exactly where the real value of this case for you begins. From the outset, this was never an academic debate about jurisdiction. It was a question that every company holding rights in more than one country eventually faces: how do you enforce your rights efficiently without burning your budget on ten parallel proceedings?
Brussels Ia Regulation: The Underrated Article 4
While searching for a solution, the BSH team came across Article 4 of the Brussels Ia Regulation. The underlying idea is simple: a person can generally be sued in the country where that person is based. In the BSH case, that pointed toward the Swedish home court, because Electrolux is headquartered in Stockholm.
For a long time, this rule played no real role in patent practice. The widely held view was that cross-border patent litigation in Europe was effectively dead the moment a defendant challenged the validity of the patent. Anyone wanting to enforce a patent across several countries appeared to have no choice but to litigate country by country.
Heilein and his team questioned that assumption instead of simply accepting it. This is the point I find most instructive: challenging accepted assumptions in your own field is often the difference between a standard solution and a strategic one. In 2020, the team decided to file the action in Sweden, aware that they were looking at a possibility, not a guarantee.
Cross-Border Enforcement: The Three Questions Referred to Luxembourg
After Electrolux challenged the validity of the patents, the Swedish home court declared itself not competent to hear the case. BSH appealed, and the Swedish Court of Appeal agreed to refer three questions to the European Court of Justice.
The first question addressed the core problem: does a home court that would otherwise have jurisdiction over an infringement claim lose that jurisdiction simply because the defendant argues the patent is invalid?
The second question concerned a feature common to many legal systems, including Germany’s, where infringement and validity are decided in separate proceedings.
The third question originally concerned Turkey. Today, most people immediately think of the United Kingdom, and some even think of US patents. Originally, the question was simpler: do the same jurisdiction rules apply to patents from countries outside the European Union?
The fact that the ECJ first assigned the case to a Chamber of seven judges and later referred it to the Grand Chamber of 15 judges already signaled how much weight the Court placed on these questions.
The Judgment: What the ECJ Actually Decided
A home court does not automatically lose jurisdiction simply because the defendant argues the patent is invalid. For many years, the opposite was widely assumed to be settled law. The ECJ made clear that this reading was too narrow. The court where the defendant is based can generally continue to hear the infringement case.
One point matters for how you read this ruling: questions concerning the validity of a European patent still fall to the national courts of the country for which the patent was granted, as provided in Article 24(4) of the Brussels Ia Regulation. What is new is that the infringement case does not automatically collapse the moment validity is challenged. The home court keeps control of the overall proceeding.
For patents from EU Member States, the home court does not automatically lose jurisdiction. It assesses the validity challenge. If it looks strong, the home court may stay the infringement case. If it looks weak, the home court may proceed. For patents from non-EU countries, the home court may stay the case if a validity proceeding is already pending there, drawing on Articles 33 and 34 of the Brussels Ia Regulation. The result is a considerably more flexible system than most observers expected
.
Patents from Outside the EU: Long-Arm Jurisdiction
The part of the judgment with the greatest international reach concerns patents from countries outside the EU. The ECJ ruled that the special jurisdiction rule for patent validity generally does not apply to non-European patents. That means the general rule can apply instead, opening the door for infringement claims based on non-European patents to be brought before a home court where the defendant is based in the EU. Commentators quickly started calling this “long-arm jurisdiction.”
One clarification matters here, because it tends to get lost in the public discussion: the ECJ did not say that a European home court can revoke or invalidate a foreign patent. That remains a matter for the authorities and courts of the country that granted it. What the ECJ said is that a European home court may assess the claims between the parties. That distinction is essential to how you should read this ruling.
Consequences in Practice: Fujifilm, Regeneron, and Onesta
Three recent cases show how quickly practice is already adapting to the new possibilities.
Fujifilm v. Kodak: the Düsseldorf Local Division of the Unified Patent Court accepted jurisdiction over the UK part of a European patent even before the ECJ delivered its judgment, building on reasoning the Advocate General had already signaled in the BSH case. In June 2026, the UPC Court of Appeal further developed that approach based on the principles confirmed in BSH.
Regeneron v. Formycon: the Munich home court applied the BSH framework and granted a Europe-wide injunction based on a European patent, one of the first examples of a national home court putting the BSH logic into practice.
Onesta v. BMW: this case shows the debate has moved well beyond Europe. After Onesta attempted to assert two US patents before the Munich home court, BMW obtained an anti-suit injunction from a Texas federal court. Judge Albright took the view that US patents should generally be decided by US courts. The injunction was directed against Onesta, not against the Munich court, and Onesta has appealed the Texas decision. The Munich home court stayed the proceeding but did not reject its own jurisdiction. Whether a European home court can ultimately decide infringement claims based on US patents remains an open question, one that has turned from a European jurisdiction issue into an international jurisdiction conflict.
What This Means for Your Company
Heilein sums up twenty years of litigation in three lessons, and I share this assessment without reservation when advising my Mittelstand clients.
First: patent enforcement has become more international. National litigation still matters, but companies should think across borders from the very beginning, not only once the first cease-and-desist letter has been sent.
Second: choice of forum now carries real strategic weight. Where you bring a case can matter just as much as the legal arguments themselves.
Third: long-term commitment pays off. Major developments rarely result from a single filing or a single hearing. They come from pursuing a clear strategy consistently over many years.
For you as a managing director, R&D lead, or Head of IP at an innovative Mittelstand company, this translates into two concrete points. First, if you hold rights in several European countries and a competitor infringes them, you no longer necessarily have to fund five or six parallel national proceedings. A single action at the infringer’s home base can be the economically smarter option. Second, and this side of the ruling gets less attention in public discussion, if your company is based in Germany and operates across several countries, you can now be sued at your own home base over patent infringement claims tied to activities in other countries. That risk belongs in every freedom-to-operate analysis and in every assessment tied to acquisitions or market entry.
Here is the full transcript of the interview:
Host
Today’s interview guest is Dr. Ernst-Peter Heilein. If you don’t know Ernst-Peter, he is a German and European patent attorney, the founder of HEILEIN IP LAW, and a long-time IP leader at BSH Home Appliances. Thank you for being on IP Fridays.
Answer
Yeah, great to be here!
BLOCK 1 – THE PERSON BEHIND THE CASE
Host
When looking at your career, one thing stands out: you never really followed the traditional path of either private practice or industry.
Er, how did your professional journey begin, actually?
Answer
My professional roots are actually in private practice.
After qualifying as a Patent Attorney, I worked in private practice and fairly early founded my own law firm, which later became HEILEIN IP LAW.
Host
So you never completely left private practice behind?
Answer
Exactly.
In 2005, I had the opportunity to take on additional responsibilities on the BSH side.
There, I was able to build and lead a new unit within the IP organization.
The team was responsible for patents in the small appliances business, as well as global design and trademark protection.
At the same time, I helped build an international network of internal and external IP counsel and coordinated their work.
Host
That still sounds fairly like traditional IP work. When did international disputes become part of your career?
Answer
Over time, my focus gradually shifted from traditional IP protection to strategic enforcement.
That included anti-counterfeiting activities, global trademark and design matters, and cross-border patent disputes.
Host
So your work became more about enforcing rights rather than simply obtaining and managing them, right?
Answer
Exactly.
And that development eventually led me to play a strategic role in the case BSH Home Appliances versus Electrolux, a case that still accompanies me today.
Host
Looking back now — from private practice, to building an international IP organization, and eventually becoming involved in a case before the European Court of Justice — did you ever imagine that path?
Answer
No, not at all.
Looking back, this combination of private practice, responsibilities on the business side, and international enforcement experience turned out to be very useful when our case eventually reached the European Court of Justice.
BLOCK 2 – HOW IT ALL STARTED
Host
Yeah, talking about this case. The case BSH versus Electrolux started long before it reached the European Court of Justice.
When did the story actually begin?
Answer
The story actually begins much earlier than most people would expect.
The invention itself dates back to 2001 and concerns a new vacuum cleaner technology.
In 2006, we identified what we believed to be an unauthorized use of the invention and contacted Electrolux to clarify the situation.
The European patent in suit was granted in 2009 and validated in a number of European countries.
At the time, nobody could have imagined that this would eventually lead to a decision of the European Court of Justice almost twenty years later.
Host
Wow, 20 years! That’s a long time. So, at first this was simply a normal patent dispute?
Answer
Yes, absolutely!
After many years of opposition and appeal proceedings before the European Patent Office, we were finally able to defend the patent successfully in late 2018.
Less than one year later, in the summer of 2019, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf found that certain Electrolux vacuum cleaner models infringed the patent.
Host
Er, at that point, one might think, that the patent owner had achieved its goal, right?
Answer
That is what many people would think.
But that judgment did not bring the dispute to an end. A new challenge emerged.
The patent had been validated in many European countries.
Winning in one country, like Germany, did not automatically solve the enforcement issue in all the other countries.
Host
What was the practical problem then?
Answer
We were facing a very simple question:
How do we enforce a patent that exists in many countries?
And how do we prevent claims from becoming time-barred without filing separate infringement actions in every single country?
Doing that would not only be legally complex.
It would also require a huge amount of time, effort, and money.
Host
That sounds less like a major legal question and more like a business problem.
Answer
Exactly.
At the beginning, this was not an academic discussion about jurisdiction.
It was a very practical business question.
How can we enforce our rights efficiently without running parallel lawsuits all over Europe?
That was the real challenge we were trying to solve.
BLOCK 3 – THE IDEA OF A CENTRAL ACTION
Host
So, how did the idea of one central action emerge?
Answer
While looking for possible solutions, we came across Article 4 of the Brussels Ia Regulation.
The idea behind that rule is very simple.
In general, a person can be sued in the country where that person is based.
In our case, that pointed us toward the Swedish home court because Electrolux is based in Stockholm.
Host
That sounds like a fairly ordinary jurisdiction rule.
Answer
Yes.
And that was exactly what made it interesting.
Article 4 is the general rule.
The question was whether that rule could also be used for patent infringement claims covering several countries.
Host
Was that a common approach at the time?
Answer
No.
Quite the opposite.
Many people believed that cross-border patent litigation in Europe was effectively dead.
Host
That sounds rather dramatic. Why did people think that?
Answer
Because there was a widely held view that a central patent case could be stopped as soon as the defendant challenged the validity of the patent.
As a result, many companies assumed they had no real choice but to litigate country by country.
Host
Yet you decided to look at the issue differently.
Answer
Yes.
Sometimes it is worth taking a fresh look at accepted assumptions.
We felt that Article 4 might play a much more important role than many people believed.
Host
So at that point, you already saw an opportunity, right?
Answer
Yes, we saw a possibility!
Not a guarantee.
But we believed there was a strong legal basis for bringing all claims before the Swedish home court.
Host
And that eventually led to the lawsuit being filed in Sweden, right?
Answer
Exactly.
In 2020, we decided to file the action in Sweden.
That followed our success before the European Patent Office in late 2018 and in the Düsseldorf infringement proceedings in 2019.
At that stage, our objective was very practical.
We were simply trying to find an efficient way to enforce rights that exist in many countries.
Host
At that point, you already think the case might end up before the European Court of Justice?
Answer
No.
Not at all.
We were focused on solving a business problem.
The idea that the case would eventually reach the European Court of Justice came much later.
BLOCK 4 – THE OBSTACLE: GAT v. LuK
Host
You mentioned that, er, many people believed cross-border patent litigation in Europe was no longer a realistic option.
Why was that?
Answer
The main reason was an earlier decision of the European Court of Justice known as GAT versus LuK, decided in 2006.
For many years, that decision was understood to mean that a home court could lose its ability to hear a patent infringement case as soon as the defendant challenged the validity of the patent.
In practice, that understanding made many cross-border patent cases extremely difficult.
As a result, many people believed that cross-border patent litigation was not effective.
Host
And yet you decided to follow exactly that path, right?
Answer
Yes.
Sometimes it is worth questioning assumptions that have been accepted for many years.
We believed that Article 4 of the Brussels Ia Regulation played a more important role than many people thought.
That is why, in 2020, we decided to file the case in Sweden.
Host
And at that point, did you already realize that the case might eventually reach the European Court of Justice?
Answer
No.
Not at all.
Our goal was simply to find a practical solution to a real enforcement problem.
The idea that this would eventually become a case before the European Court of Justice was far from our minds.
BLOCK 5 – THE QUESTIONS REFERRED TO THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE
Host
So, how did the case eventually reach the European Court of Justice then?
Answer
After we filed the lawsuit in Sweden in 2020, Electrolux challenged the validity of the patents.
The Swedish home court then concluded that it could not hear the case and declared itself not competent to proceed.
We appealed that decision, because the issues were important and affected far more than just our case.
We suggested that several questions should be referred to the European Court of Justice.
The Swedish Court of Appeal agreed and sent those questions to Luxembourg.
Host
So, what were these main questions?
Answer
At the heart of the case, there were three questions:
First: if a home court has jurisdiction over a patent infringement case, does it lose that jurisdiction simply because the defendant argues that the patent is invalid?
Second: Does it make a difference if the national legal system requires validity issues to be decided in a separate proceeding?
And third: Do this jurisdiction rules also apply to patents from countries outside the European Union?
Host
The third question sounds particularly interesting.
Answer
Yes, at the time, the discussion in our case focused on Turkey.
Today, many people immediately think about the United Kingdom, and some even think about US patents.
But originally, the question was much simpler.
We wanted to know, whether the same jurisdiction rules also apply when patents from non-European countries are involved.
Host
And, did you realize how important that third question might become?
Answer
No, certainly not to that extent.
At the beginning, most of the discussion focused on the relationship between the different jurisdiction rules within Europe.
Only later did it become clear that the European Court of Justice’s answers might have consequences far beyond the European Union.
Host
So, how did the European Court of Justice react then?
Answer
That was actually quite interesting.
The European Court of Justice first heard the case before a Chamber of seven judges.
Later, it referred the case to the Grand Chamber of 15 judges.
That already showed that the European Court of Justice considered the issues to be important.
And when the judgment finally came out, some of the answers were very different from what many observers had expected.
BLOCK 6 – THE DECISION OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE
Host
Let’s talk about the European Court of Justice’s answers.
What was, in your view, the most important part of the decision?
Answer
The most important point was this:
A home court does not automatically lose jurisdiction just because the defendant argues that the patent is invalid.
For many years, many people believed exactly the opposite.
The European Court of Justice made it clear that this understanding was too narrow.
The home court where the defendant is based can generally continue to hear the infringement case.
That is really the key message of the decision.
Host
Why is that so important?
Answer
Because it gives new momentum to cross-border patent enforcement in Europe.
Before this decision, many people assumed that a defendant could effectively stop a central infringement case simply by challenging the validity of the patent.
The European Court of Justice made clear that this is not automatically the case.
Host
Does that mean the home court hearing the infringement case will now also decide whether the patent is valid?
Answer
No, and that is a very important point.
The European Court of Justice confirmed that questions about the validity of a European patent should still be decided by the national courts of the country for which the patent was granted, as provided for in Article 24(4) of the Brussels Ia Regulation.
What is new, is that the infringement case does not automatically fall apart because of a validity challenge.
The home court can keep control of the overall case.
Host
So, how does that work in practice?
Answer
The European Court of Justice gives the home court some flexibility.
For patents from Member States of the European Union, the home court does not automatically lose its power if the defendant says the patent is invalid.
The home court can look at the validity challenge. If it seems strong, the home court may stay the infringement case. If it seems weak, the home court may continue the infringement case.
For patents from countries outside the European Union, the home court may also stay the case if there is already a validity case pending in that country. In such situations, Articles 33 and 34 of the Brussels Ia Regulation may apply.
That creates a much more flexible system than many people expected.
Host
Er, we have discussed the implications for patents from Member States of the European Union, but a lot of attention has been given to another part of the decision, that we already talked about briefly, namely patents from countries outside the European Union.
Answer
Absolutely, and that may be the part of the judgment with the biggest international impact.
Host
Why?
Answer
Because the European Court of Justice decided that the special jurisdiction rule for patent validity does not generally apply to patents from non-European countries.
In simple terms, that means the general rule can still apply.
And that opens the possibility of bringing infringement cases based on non-European patents before the home court where the defendant is based in the European Union.
Host
That sounds like a very far-reaching statement.
Answer
It is.
That is why many commentators started talking about what is often called “long-arm jurisdiction.”
In other words, a European home court may, under certain circumstances, deal with infringement claims relating to patents from countries outside the European Union.
Host
So, many listeners may now wonder:
Can a Swedish or a German home court really decide a dispute involving a British or Turkish patent?
Answer
Ah, we need to be careful here.
The European Court of Justice did not say that a European home court can cancel or revoke a foreign patent.
That remains a matter for the authorities and national courts of the country that granted the patent.
What the European Court of Justice said is that a European home court may assess the claims between the parties in a dispute.
That is an important distinction.
Host
Did you realize during the proceedings how important this part of the decision might become?
Answer
Not to this extent.
We started with a very practical enforcement problem.
Only later did it become clear that the European Court of Justice’s answers might have consequences far beyond the original case.
Today, the decision is discussed not only in connection with Turkish patents, but also British patents and even possible claims involving US patents.
Host
If you had to summarize the decision in one sentence, and I know, this is a very difficult task, what would that sentence be?
Answer
The European Court of Justice did not re-invent cross-border patent enforcement in Europe.
But after many years, it clearly gave it much more room to develop.
BLOCK 7 – THE REACTION OF THE IP COMMUNITY
Host
So, how was the decision received after it was published?
Answer
Ah, the reaction was very strong.
It quickly became clear that many people saw the decision as much more than just another patent case.
Many articles and commentaries described it as an important development in European patent litigation.
Host
Did that surprise you?
Answer
To some extent, yes.
Of course, we knew that the questions referred to the European Court of Justice were important.
But I was surprised by how quickly the decision became a major topic of discussion across the European patent community.
Host
Er, you later presented the decision at several conferences yourself, right?
Answer
Yes.
The discussion started right away.
I had the opportunity to discuss and present the case at several conferences and events, including the annual VPP conference in Germany and the Ingolstadt Patent Symposium.
I recently received an invitation to serve as a panel speaker on cross-border litigation at the AIPPI World Congress 2026 in Hamburg.
What struck me most was that both internal and external IP counsel were trying to understand the practice consequences of the decision.
Host
So, what was the question you were asked most often?
Answer
Almost always the same one:
How far does this decision really go?
People wanted to know whether this was simply a correction of earlier case law or whether it marked the beginning of a new phase in cross-border patent enforcement.
Host
And what did you say?
Answer
I would describe it as: neither a revolution nor a minor adjustment.
The European Court of Justice did not rewrite the system.
But it clearly changed the balance between the different jurisdiction rules.
That is why I believe the decision will continue to be discussed for many years, both in practice and in academia.
Host
Er, one year later, the case received the Managing IP Award as the “Europe Impact Case of the Year.”
What did that recognition mean to you?
Answer
First of all, it was a great honor for everyone involved.
But for me, the most important thing was the message behind the award.
The award showed that the decision affects much more than the parties involved in the case.
It has an impact on European patent practice as a whole.
And it also shows that the underlying jurisdiction questions reach far beyond patent law.
They are relevant whenever companies have to enforce rights across borders in an increasing international world.
That is what makes this case special.
Host
You often describe this case as a team effort.
Answer
Absolutely.
A case of this size is never the work of one person.
Many people contributed over many years.
On the BSH side, team members from different functions played an important role throughout the proceedings.
And we worked closely with external advisors in several countries.
So I see the award as recognition of a shared achievement rather than an individual success.
Host
Looking at the discussions today, would you say the debate is over?
Answer
Not at all.
I actually think we are only at the beginning.
There are still many practical questions that home courts will have to answer in the coming years.
That is exactly why the decision remains so interesting.
BLOCK 8 – WHAT DOES THE DECISION MEAN IN PRACTICE?
Host
Let’s move from legal theory to practical business implications.
What does this decision mean for patent owners and companies?
Answer
In my view, the biggest change is strategic.
Patent owners now have better opportunities to bring cross-border disputes together in one central proceeding.
At the same time, companies need to be aware that they may face claims at their European headquarters covering activities in several countries.
So the decision creates opportunities, but it also creates new risks.
Host
That sounds really like a significant shift; right?
Answer
I would call it a rebalancing rather than a revolution.
The European Court of Justice did not create a completely new system.
But it made clear that the general rule — suing a defendant where it is based — plays a much bigger role than many people had assumed.
As a result, the court at the defendant’s home base becomes much more important strategically.
Host
In the patent community, people often talk about cases such as Fujifilm v. Kodak, or Regeneron v. Formycon or Onesta v. BMW.
Why are those cases attracting so much attention now?
Answer
Because they show how quickly practice is already adapting to the new possibilities.
Fujifilm was important because it was one of the first UPC cases to test the logic that was later confirmed in BSH.
At that time, the BSH case was already pending before the European Court of Justice, and the Advocate General had expressed a view that pointed in that direction.
Against that background, the Düsseldorf Local Division accepted jurisdiction over the UK part of a European patent even before the European Court of Justice delivered its judgment.
In June 2026, based on the principles confirmed in BSH, the UPC Court of Appeal further developed that approach.
Host
And what happened in Regeneron v. Formycon ?
Answer
In the Regeneron case, the Munich home court applied the approach confirmed in BSH and granted a Europe-wide injunction based on a European patent. That was one of the first examples of a national home court using the BSH framework in practice.
That demonstrates that the decision is not just an academic discussion.
It already has practical consequences.
Host
And what about the Onesta case?
Answer
The Onesta case shows that the debate has moved beyond Europe.
After Onesta attempted to assert two U.S. patents before the Munich home court, BMW obtained an anti-suit injunction from a Texas federal court.
Judge Albright took the view that U.S. patents should generally be decided by U.S. courts.
The Onesta case therefore illustrates that the limits of the BSH logic are now being tested internationally.
Host
Did that end the proceedings in Munich?
Answer
Not necessarily.
What makes the case interesting is that the Texas injunction was directed against Onesta, not against the Munich home court.
At the same time, Onesta appealed Judge Albright’s decision in the United States.
The Munich home court therefore decided to stay the case for the time being.
Importantly, however, the Munich home court did not reject its own jurisdiction.
So, at least for the moment, the underlying question remains open.
Host
Can a European home court ultimately decide infringement claims based on U.S. patents?
Answer
That question has not yet been answered.
But the case has already shown that such an attempt can trigger strong reactions outside Europe.
In that sense, the debate has moved from a European jurisdiction question to an international jurisdiction conflict.
Host
For our audience of internal and external IP counsel, what are the main lessons from this decision?
Answer
For me, there are three key takeaways.
First:
Patent enforcement has become more international.
National litigation remains important, but companies should think across borders from the very beginning.
Second:
The choice of forum is becoming more important.
Where you bring a case may be just as important as the legal arguments themselves.
And third:
Long-term commitment matters.
This case shows that major developments rarely happen because of a single filing or a single hearing.
They usually result from pursuing a clear strategy consistently over many years.
Host
Do you think this decision will also influence the Unified Patent Court, the UPC?
Answer
Yes, I believe so.
The decision fits into a broader trend toward more centralized patent litigation.
Both, the UPC and the BSH decision are driven by the same idea:
Handling cross-border disputes more efficiently and more consistently.
What is interesting is that many of the questions were faced in BSH versus Electrolux are now reappearing in a new form before the UPC.
Cases like Fujifilm versus Kodak show that the discussion about jurisdiction, scope, and cross-border effects is far from over.
Institutions may be new.
But the underlying challenge remains the same:
How do we enforce patents effectively across borders?
Host
Some commentators even see this as a step toward a more independent European patent judiciary.
Do you agree?
Answer
To some extent, yes.
Professor Hanns Ullrich, who supervised my doctoral studies on the legal protection of a then new semiconductor technology many years ago, recently observed that the UPC is gradually developing its own European case law.[DH1]
I think that is — again — a very accurate observation.
If you look at the developments since BSH and the first UPC decisions, you can see that European patent litigation is becoming more connected.
National courts will remain important.
But at the same time, we are seeing a more integrated European patent system taking shape.
How far that development will go remains to be seen.
Host
Looking back on the entire journey — from a vacuum cleaner patent, through litigation in several countries, all the way to the European Court of Justice and an award-winning decision — what is your personal conclusion?
Answer
My main conclusion is that innovation needs effective legal protection.
But it also requires the willingness to challenge established assumptions and explore new approaches.
For me, the BSH versus Electrolux case shows that persistence, teamwork, a willingness to challenge accepted assumptions, and a long-term strategic view can sometimes lead to developments that go far beyond the original dispute.
BLOCK 9 – THE PERSON BEHIND THE DECISION
Host
Ernst-Peter, today we have talked a lot about jurisdiction, patent enforcement, and European case law.
When you look back at this journey, which has lasted almost twenty years, what impressed you most?
Answer
Probably the realization that major developments rarely follow a straight line.
When we started thinking about the case, we were dealing with a very practical problem.
Nobody said: Let’s create a landmark decision of the European Court of Justice.
We were simply looking for a reasonable and practical solution for a company.
The fact that this would eventually lead to a decision with Europe-wide impact was something nobody could foresee at the time.
Host
Were there moments when you thought the case might fail?
Answer
Of course.
Whenever a case lasts many years, there will be setbacks, new questions, and unexpected developments.
That is exactly why persistence is so important.
In the end, success is often not about one filing or one hearing.
It is about staying focused on a clear objective over a long period of time.
Host
You often talk about teamwork.
Is that one of the main lessons from this case?
Answer
Absolutely.
A case of this size requires commitment from many people and institutes over many years.
On the BSH side, my role was to help maintain the strategic direction and long-term commitment that such a case requires.
At the same time, experts from different functions within BSH contributed technical expertise, testing, documentation, and practical support throughout the proceedings.
On the legal side, Roman Sedlmaier and his team at IP-Counsels Gigerich & Sedlmaier (IPCGS) helped develop the cross-border litigation strategy and the overall case architecture.
Our Swedish litigation team then carried the arguments through all stages of the proceedings.
Looking back, it was the combination of institutional commitment, technical expertise, strategic leadership, well-designed case architecture, and consistent execution that made the difference.
Host
One final question.
What advice would you give to young internal or external IP counsel?
Answer
Stay curious: Don’t be afraid to question accepted assumptions.
Be patient: Intellectual property is usually a marathon, not a sprint.
And never forget that every patent dispute involves an invention, a business, and many people who have worked hard to bring that innovation to market.
For me, that connection between technology, law, and strategy is what still makes this profession so fascinating today.
Host
Ernst-Peter, thank you very much for joining us today on IP Fridays.
Answer
Thank you.
It was a pleasure to be here.Creator Economy Law: What Every Creator Needs to Know About AI, Platforms, and Their Rights – Interview with Franklin Graves of Linkedin – IP Fridays Podcast – Episode 176
26/06/2026 | 36 minMy co-host Ken Suzan and I are welcoming you the episode 176 of the IP Fridays Podcast. Today’s interview guest is returning guest Franklin Graves, who is a senior counsel at Linkedin and teaching IP law at Emerson College. With my co-host Ken Suzan he is discussing how the law for creators has dramatically changed in the past years.
Franklin Graves is expressing his personal views and not the views of Linkedin or Microsoft. He is talking about the paper “Upload Complete” before he joined Linkedin.
Bio: https://www.linkedin.com/in/franklingraves/
Paper: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5271442
Website: https://creatoreconomylaw.com/
But before we jump into this interview, I have news for you!
Richard Meade, a judge on the UK High Court and one of the most prominent figures in European patent law, was appointed Lord Justice of Appeal at the British Court of Appeal on June 12, 2026. Meade played a key role in numerous landmark British patent decisions, particularly in the area of standard-essential patents (SEPs) and FRAND licenses.
In Insulet Corp. v. EOFlow Co., No. 2025-1807, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit completely overturned the original $452 million judgment (which had already been reduced by the District Court to $59.4 million) in favor of Insulet.
In its decision of June 2, 2026, in the case of Fujifilm v. Kodak, the UPC Board of Appeal provided comprehensive clarifications regarding so-called “long-arm jurisdiction”—that is, the question of whether the UPC can also rule on national patent claims outside the UPC territory (such as in the United Kingdom). In 14 guiding principles, the judges established specific procedural rules for various categories of cases. There is no automatic UPC jurisdiction over national patent claims outside the UPC territory.
The Munich Regional Court has issued an arrest warrant against the managing director of Polytech Health & Aesthetics GmbH because he is alleged to have continued to exploit the Brazilian company Silimed’s patent for breast implants despite a preliminary injunction.
A number of IT and automotive industry associations—which are among the most frequent users of Inter Partes Reviews (IPR) at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office—have filed an amicus brief with the Supreme Court, urging the Court to grant Google’s certiorari petition.
An attorney for a Las Vegas performer has asked a California federal judge to temporarily prohibit Taylor Swift from using “The Life of a Showgirl” as a trademark while the trademark lawsuit is pending. Swift’s attorney called the lawsuit baseless.
And now let’s hear Ken discuss creator law with Franklin!
AI, Platform Law, and the Creator Economy: What Businesses Need to Know Now
Franklin Graves has spent his entire career watching digital content move through systems that most people never see. He started in marketing at a major music label right out of law school, then represented individual creators on YouTube in a pro bono capacity, then moved to the platform side at Eventbrite, and today works as Senior Product Counsel at LinkedIn, where he focuses on AI, data, and the regulatory questions that come with both. His recently published law review article, Upload Complete: An Introduction to Creator Economy Law, is the first academic paper to address the creator economy as a distinct legal field. In a recent episode of the IP Fridays podcast, he spoke with host Kenneth Suzan about responsible AI development, platform regulation, and what it actually means to own your audience in a world where the rules keep changing overnight.
From Content Creator to Platform Lawyer
The through-line in Graves’ career is a genuine understanding of how content moves from an idea in someone’s head to an audience on a screen. That experience, he argues, is precisely what in-house counsel needs right now. Lawyers working on AI and product development cannot afford to sit at a distance from the technology they are advising on. They need to use the tools, experience them as a creator or end user would, and understand the nuances of how a product actually operates before it reaches the public. Understanding the product first is the precondition for everything else.
That philosophy translates directly into how he approaches responsible AI implementation. The landscape of AI standards is crowded: NIST frameworks, the EU AI Act, sector-specific guidance, and a growing body of industry-adopted best practices. The challenge for in-house counsel is not knowing that these standards exist. It is making them actionable for the engineering and product teams they support. Abstract principles need to become concrete controls and workflows. Graves offers one practical shortcut: most companies already have open source software review processes that involve the right stakeholders, the right sign-off levels, and the right security checks. Layering the specifics of generative AI or large language models onto those existing processes is far more efficient than building something new from scratch.
A Fragmented Regulatory World
The geopolitical dimension of AI regulation is something Graves thinks about constantly in his role at LinkedIn. The EU AI Act, shifting US executive orders, and country-specific approaches to data privacy have created a regulatory environment that can change the rules of the game without warning. His analogy is instructive: creators have long understood what it means to build a community on a platform they do not own. An algorithm change, a policy update, or a government ban can wipe out years of audience-building overnight. Businesses deploying AI tools globally now face a structurally similar problem. The response, for creators and for platforms alike, is to build resilience rather than rely on stability that may not last.
TikTok is the clearest recent example. When the platform faced the prospect of being shut down in the United States on national security grounds, it triggered a broader conversation about platform dependence that had been building for years. Creators who had invested their entire business in one platform suddenly confronted the possibility that their audience could simply disappear. The lesson is not that platforms are bad. It is that concentration of any kind, whether it is your audience, your data pipeline, or your regulatory compliance strategy, creates fragility.
What Is a Creator, Legally Speaking?
One of the central contributions of Graves’ law review article is definitional. The terminology matters more than it might seem. When courts and regulators talk about creators without a shared understanding of what that word means, the resulting legal analysis tends to miss the mark. Graves draws a distinction between users who post content, creators who post with the intent to build an audience and eventually monetize it, and influencers, a subset of creators who are actively running a small business through their content. The difference is intent. A parent posting family photos on Facebook is a user. Someone building a subscription community around their professional expertise is running a business, and the legal framework that applies to them should reflect that.
That distinction matters practically when it comes to liability. As more creators build their own platforms, whether through custom membership sites, open source tools like Ghost, or federated social networks, they take on obligations that previously fell to large platforms: content moderation policies, privacy notices, terms of service, and compliance with data regulations across multiple jurisdictions. A creator in Tennessee running a membership platform with subscribers in Germany is operating a global business, whether they think of themselves that way or not.
Protecting Children Online: A Question Without a Clean Answer
The tension between age verification and privacy is one of the more difficult problems in platform law right now. Australia, several European countries, and a growing number of US states have introduced or passed minimum age requirements for social media accounts. The technical challenge is real: verifying age online requires collecting identifying information, and collecting identifying information creates privacy risk, particularly for the young people the laws are designed to protect. Who should bear the responsibility for that verification is also unresolved. Is it the platform? The app store? The mobile operating system? Graves does not pretend there is a clean answer, but he points to the mobile layer as an underexplored option. The Apple App Store and Google Play Store already have significant leverage over which apps reach users on their devices. Whether that leverage should extend to age verification is a question that deserves more attention than it currently receives.
The Right of Publicity in the Age of AI
Voice cloning, digital replicas, and AI-generated synthetic media have pushed the right of publicity into territory that traditional IP law was not designed to cover. Trademark law, copyright law, and existing publicity rights each capture part of the problem but none of them covers it completely. The result, as Graves describes it, is a period of experimentation: lawyers filing trademarks on vocal sounds and phrases, states updating their publicity statutes to explicitly mention artificial intelligence, and entertainment unions negotiating over who controls a performance and any AI-generated iterations of it.
Tennessee’s Elvis Act is a concrete example of the legislative response: the state updated its right of publicity law to include voice and to reference AI directly. Similar efforts are underway elsewhere. The underlying challenge is calibrating protection so that it gives creators and performers meaningful control over their likeness and voice without foreclosing the development of generative AI systems that depend on broad rights to process and learn from content. Somewhere between those two interests, a workable legal framework needs to emerge.
The brand deal context may be where the issue becomes most immediately practical. When a brand partners with an influencer and the campaign involves generative AI in any form, the contract needs to address control explicitly. Who has final approval over how the influencer’s likeness or voice is used in AI-generated deliverables? What happens to those assets after the campaign ends? These are not hypothetical questions. They are contract drafting problems that any brand counsel or creator attorney should be addressing today.
What Comes Next
Graves is cautious about predictions, but his sense of direction is clear. The regulatory environment will continue to fragment before it converges. The right of publicity will be updated, imperfectly, in more jurisdictions. Creators will continue to move toward owning more of their infrastructure. And the lawyers who do this work best will be the ones who understand the technology well enough to translate it into practical, defensible decisions for the people they advise.
Full Transcript:
Ken Suzan: Thank you, Rolf. Our returning guest today is Franklin Graves. Franklin is the founder and editor of Creator Economy Law, a website and newsletter that educates creator economy professionals on the intersection of law and policy with the world of creators, brands, and platforms. Franklin also published the first law review article focused on the creator economy, Upload Complete, an introduction to creator economy law. He regularly appears across news and media outlets as a commentator and contributor with a focus on educating creators and raising awareness of all legal aspects of the creator economy. Franklin is based in Nashville, Tennessee.
Ken Suzan: Franklin was invited to participate as one of the creators and creator economy professionals in the first ever White House creator economy conference. Franklin works full time as a product counsel at LinkedIn Corporation. As a member of the product and data team, he focuses on emerging issues in AI and data. Franklin previously held roles on the technology law group at HCA Healthcare, the commercial legal team at Eventbrite, and the business and legal affairs team at Naxos Music Group. Welcome back Franklin to the IP Fridays podcast.
Franklin Graves: Thank you so much for having me. It is exciting to be back and reflecting over the last decade since I last joined and also the paper that I wrote that dives into this in more detail. So I really appreciate it. And yes, full disclosure, I currently work for LinkedIn, which is a subsidiary of Microsoft. I’m here in my personal capacity to talk about this, the paper I wrote before joining LinkedIn and all of that. So thank you so much for having me back.
Ken Suzan: Excellent. So Franklin, since your last appearance on IP Fridays in 2017, your career has evolved significantly. You are now senior product counsel at LinkedIn focusing on AI and data. How has working inside a major tech platform changed your perspective on the legal frameworks governing digital content compared to when you were viewing it purely from the creator side?
Franklin Graves: I appreciate that question because when I wrote the article, I did not work for LinkedIn. And I had been coming from a history in my career where I, right out of law school, worked for a record label like we talked about almost 10 years ago. And I was on the content creation side. I’ve represented a major distributor of classical music digitally at the time. And that was my first exposure to understanding how content was taken from the initial inception stage from creators and routed through all the various digital platforms that were at the time still evolving and even arguably still today continue to evolve. The early days of YouTube Music launching and then Apple Music launching, and then going through all the phases of high-res audio and everything that came after that. So that was an interesting perspective to start my career with. And then I went to Eventbrite, which is a ticketing platform, but was also focused on elevating event creators. They kind of took on that moniker of “Hey, we are event creators that we support.” And that was arguably my first exposure to the platform side, the tech platform side of it, because Eventbrite is a platform. And so then I evolved from there in my personal capacity, in a pro bono capacity representing individual creators across the YouTube space. And that’s what we talked about a little bit back when I first came on the podcast.
Franklin Graves: Over the last decade, it’s been a chance to grow my own understanding of the creator economy. The terminology “creator economy” came around. And then now on the other side of it, having written the article and all that, and now being fully in-house at LinkedIn, I truly am experiencing a social media platform. LinkedIn is of course arguably way more than just the platform itself. There are so many different avenues to it, but it is a chance for me to understand what it is like working for a company that is operating the platform that people are distributing content on. There’s a user journey to content and all of that. So it’s definitely enhanced and given me a different perspective from a major tech platform side. And part of my role at LinkedIn is really heavily focused on understanding regulation and how that from an AI and data perspective impacts the company. And so I’ve been really leveling up my game over the last year and a half that I’ve been here, understanding mostly EU regulations, but also US regulations that are still in their infancy when it comes to AI. But really when it comes to privacy and data, those are pretty well established across the board. It’s been kind of a combination of what I learned at Eventbrite, because I went to Eventbrite when GDPR was going into effect. And so that was an eyes-wide-open moment of getting in the weeds with negotiating data processing agreements, understanding data transfers and cross-border data transfers and the like. So it’s been kind of an evolution as the laws and regulations have evolved. So has my career, so has my own understanding, so have the platforms’ responses to those laws and regulations. And I’m sure that probably resonates with a lot of your listeners who have also been growing their practice and their understanding as the laws and regulations in this realm have been evolving too.
Ken Suzan: Yes, indeed. Now let’s switch gears and talk about AI. You advise on AI and data daily. As platforms integrate generative AI tools into their tech stacks, what are the most critical best practices in-house counsel should be adopting right now to embed responsible AI principles into product development?
Franklin Graves: So as an attorney, one of my key roles is to understand the technology. Even representing creators and working for creator platforms, that’s something I’m constantly trying to do: put myself in the shoes of being a creator. And I think I talked about this last time I was on, but I come from a background where I was working for a major label doing marketing, video editing, social media work. And I was creating content. I understood the whole life cycle from the inception point of an idea to execution and then to the final delivery and distribution of that content to an audience within a major music label. And so part of that is the same thing that I think attorneys, especially in-house, should be doing: using the tools that the product and engineering teams are either developing in-house or partnering with third parties to develop, or a combination of the two. Using them, understanding them, using them as a creator would, using them as an end user or a client or customer would. And making sure that if you understand the product and understand the nuances of how it operates, and being a part of the iterations of that internally before it fully ramps, that really gives you a chance to understand: okay, we have a lot of responsible AI principles and standards and protocols that are in existence right now, whether it’s NIST, whether it’s based on the EU AI Act or anything and everything in between. It’s understanding how to apply those and bring those into a product and an engineering environment in a way that is practical and actionable for the people that you’re supporting, the stakeholders you’re supporting. So I think one of the critical best practices is, number one, understand the product or features that you’re supporting.
Franklin Graves: And then understand how you as an attorney can use your expertise and understanding of responsible AI practices, whether it’s a regulatory standard or an industry-adopted standard or a hybrid of the two, to leverage those and implement those, break those down and make them into actionable controls and processes and flows that work within your existing infrastructure. That’s a lot of high-level talk, but that’s the general idea. One concrete example we talk about frequently is with open source AI. If you’re working with a product team or an engineering team that is taking an off-the-shelf open source model and bringing that in-house, a lot of times companies have pre-existing open source processes that cover the use of open source software or code. Piggyback on that. That’s the easiest quick win for attorneys: leveraging your existing open source processes to just build on top of that the AI flavor and layering. It’s not very much that you have to do, but the underlying process of the key stakeholders that need to be involved in the review, whether it’s security, whether it’s executive sign-off if it gets to that point, even export control considerations should already be part of your existing open source software process. So layering in on those existing processes the specifics of generative AI or large language models that you’re trying to bring in is a great way to put this into practice.
Ken Suzan: Now looking at the geopolitical landscape that we currently have, we have the EU AI Act setting strict standards and shifting US executive orders. How should platforms and brands prepare for this fragmented regulatory environment when deploying AI tools to a global user base?
Franklin Graves: It’s a great question. It’s something that is still evolving, I think is fair to say. I would equate it, as I do in the paper that I wrote, to how creators and arguably brands don’t own the platforms that they’re building their communities on. That spawned this concept of de-platforming or going into building your own platform, a decentralized platform of sorts, and owning your community. That gives you that control and takes away the level of instability that can come for creators trying to build a business on a platform they don’t own, they don’t control when certain updates happen, when algorithms change, when tools and functionalities either become available or go away completely. So it’s very similar to what we’ve been experiencing in a regulatory environment where we have geopolitical complexities, for lack of a better term, that can overnight seemingly disrupt the way in which a platform or even a multinational brand is able to connect and reach an audience or continue to leverage the user base that they’ve built. I think TikTok is a great example of that, where it became a national security concern and suddenly it was facing an executive order that required it to be effectively disabled in the US or completely owned and operated by a US entity. All the mechanics and technicalities of whether it’s actually possible and still have a global platform with a global user base is a whole different discussion. But that’s an example of very similar considerations that are now not just a discussion point at the creator level or the individual brand level, but also in a much broader context at a platform level as well.
Ken Suzan: Franklin, let’s now shift gears and talk about your article. In your recently published journal article, Upload Complete, which we will have linked in our show notes, you advocate for a shift in terminology from internet creator law, a term used during our first podcast almost a decade ago, to creator economy law. Why is this distinction important and how does it change the way legal practitioners should view the ecosystem of creators, brands, and platforms?
Franklin Graves: Oh yes, this is part of the reason why I wanted to write the article: to lay this foundation of understanding. Because at the time I’d written the article, the term creator economy and creator had really not appeared but for maybe once in an actual court decision. And it was kind of focused on influencers and this concept, and it was just not getting it right. And so it was also, as you mentioned, when we first spoke I was even using the term internet creators. And I think that was something that was common at the time. The “internet” portion as a qualifier has since dropped off. And now for purposes of the creator economy, the term creators refers to individuals, it can be small businesses, which is what we’ve seen from a regulatory standpoint, how these small businesses are being impacted by regulations. But essentially creators in the article I pin in the context of intent. What is the intent behind the person or the small business that is posting content, trying to build a community and form a community in a virtual environment? And then that can even spill over into real physical world environments. And so the intent is kind of what I look at.
Franklin Graves: And I have a chart in the article that has a diagram showcasing the overlap of what I refer to as “users generating content.” It’s a play on the concept of user-generated content, UGC. Users generating content is that large bucket of anyone posting on a platform of some kind. And within that large bucket, that large circle, are smaller subsets. You have creators, you have brands. Those are really the two buckets you can put people into. Otherwise it’s like your grandmother or your parents posting content on Facebook or Instagram, and those are everyday users of a platform. The distinction to get into that subcategory of being a creator more so has been analyzing the intent behind the posting. Are you posting content to build an audience, to build a community, to eventually have a chance to monetize the following that you’re bringing in or sell services or something like that? Brands are posting for that reason. Creators are maybe posting for that same reason. But even within the creator category, there’s a subcategory of influencers that are trying to sell something, that are trying to build more than just an awareness of who they are, their influence. They are trying to do brand deals, partnership deals, upsells and all that, and start an actual small business aside from just the content itself that they’re creating. So that’s kind of the distinctions that I make in the paper. And that’s why it’s important to understand and lay that foundation, that anyone can post content online, but the intent, the why behind their posting that content, really does ultimately matter, especially when you’re looking at it from a court case or from a regulatory standpoint.
Ken Suzan: Now, Franklin, we’re seeing unprecedented geopolitical activity around platform ownership. For example, the US legislation targeting TikTok and Brazil’s recent temporary ban of X. How do these macro-level battles impact the day-to-day livelihood of creators? And how can they legally and operationally protect themselves?
Franklin Graves: So the shift that we’re seeing, and I alluded to this earlier in our conversation, is this concept of Web 3. And that term may or may not be really popular anymore, but that’s essentially what we’re looking at: a shift into a federated, decentralized operation of a platform. So instead of one owner, one company, one entity owning and operating the platform, it’s decentralized. Anyone can start up a server, and it’s interoperable, meaning anyone can plug and play and connect to that larger network. And it creates this unified social network experience. Within each operating node of that network, there can be your own decisions around content moderation, your own decisions around the hosting providers you use, where you’re operating out of, the terms and conditions that apply to that. But the flip side is that instead of creators posting and sharing in a closed environment run and controlled by a singular entity, you’re now experiencing a peer-to-peer type operation where your experience can change based on which server, which node, which user you’re engaging with. You might have content that’s acceptable in one area but not acceptable in another, and maybe it just doesn’t even show up in that other area.
Franklin Graves: But from a liability standpoint, as creators start to build their own networks and communities, even outside of a concept like the fediverse, it’s even down to creators building their own communities through online courses, subscription membership-based platforms that they run on their own website. There’s open source software out there, even something called Ghost, where you have memberships. And that is a creator or a small business in the creator economy that is now taking on the obligations that would typically fall upon a platform. They need to take into consideration terms and conditions, privacy policies, legal aspects, and regulatory considerations for running a platform, especially in a global world. So it’s a lot of liability that then shifts over to those small businesses and even brands sometimes that are doing the same thing. Whether it is something as simple or complex as content moderation or all the way up to monetizing an audience, this new world where creators can spin up and run a platform all dovetails back to the concept of creators not feeling like they have control in reaching the audience and the community that they’re building on an individual platform. And so this really became more mainstream conversation with TikTok and the issues around it potentially being shut down in the US. That was kind of the mindset shift and eyes opening for many creators, especially within the influencer subset, of realizing: we need to make sure that we have a way to reach the audience we’ve built if the individual platform that we’ve committed to over the last year or three years or so is no longer available. We need a way to continue that relationship outside of that one platform controlling it.
Ken Suzan: Franklin, we have a few minutes left and a number of topics. So I’m going to switch gears and talk about a few issues. First, a major emerging topic in your paper is the evolution of protecting kids online. With state-level age-gating laws like the CAADCA and the recent FTC updates to COPPA, how should platforms navigate the significant tension between strict age verification mandates and the privacy and First Amendment rights of their users?
Franklin Graves: Man, that is a whole discussion to unravel. It is a consideration that we’re seeing happen again, going back to the geopolitical nature of everything. Countries like Australia and certain countries in Europe and now even individual states in the US are trying to look at ways, and some of them have already put into place minimum age requirements before you can even sign up for an account with a social media platform. One of the things I’d just highlight quickly here is that one of the tensions is around how you verify someone’s age online and still maintain the ability to be at least pseudonymous. How do you still have a level of privacy, autonomy, and protection when it comes to having to provide something like a driver’s license or have parental consent tied and connected to an account managed by a parent in a situation where maybe it’s not appropriate or not beneficial to the child in that manner? But then maybe there are counterbalancing factors that outweigh that. All of that comes down to the technicalities of how it’s actually implemented and maintaining the sense of openness and freedom that we’ve had on the internet to date. And then the other element there is, since a lot of the internet that we think of today is more so through mobile applications, is it something that the mobile operating system providers and app store providers should be thinking about? So whether that’s the Google Play Store or the Apple App Store, where does that initial age verification need to fall? Is it at the platform level? Is it the app store or mobile device management level or something else? Yeah, there’s a lot to discuss there. And a lot of the issues we’re seeing with how the internet is changing in terms of being able to browse a website without disclosing personal information that might not have been required before is largely stemming from a focus on protecting children online.
Ken Suzan: It sounds like, Franklin, we could have another episode covering lots of issues connected with that one topic alone.
Franklin Graves: I would absolutely agree with that. There’s a lot going on there. And again, it’s different across the world. And so I know you all have a global listener base. And so there’s a lot of nuances to that whole discussion too, that are worth exploring.
Ken Suzan: Last question for today’s episode is regarding the right of publicity. With the explosion of AI-generated synthetic media, digital replicas, and voice cloning, the right of publicity is taking center stage. What are the biggest legal risks for brands partnering with influencers right now? And how can creators protect their most valuable asset, their likeness?
Franklin Graves: That’s a great question. I think we’re seeing kind of a throwing-spaghetti-against-the-wall-to-see-what-sticks approach right now by a lot of different parties, whether it’s trademark attorneys, whether it’s general entertainment attorneys or whoever. For example, we’ve seen Taylor Swift filing trademarks to protect certain sounds of her voice and phrasing that she uses. It’s a difficult area because in the realm of generative AI with deep fakes and virtual avatars, that is where it gets tricky, because traditional IP laws are just not able to fully cover that spectrum. It’s a piecemeal approach, but even then it doesn’t fully cover it. So for example, I’m based in Tennessee and a couple of years ago we had the Elvis Act that updated our right of publicity law to add voice and to explicitly reference artificial intelligence. And so that’s the kind of effort we’re probably going to continue to see: efforts to develop some framework around protecting what is essentially a privacy right, in a manner that doesn’t restrict generative AI systems from continuing to develop and operate the way they’re operating now, while layering in those protections so that in the US at least a First Amendment right doesn’t necessarily get squashed, and those traditional well-recognized efforts to not overregulate a technology in its early stages are respected.
Franklin Graves: And so I think a lot of what we’re seeing is just a need to update laws. The SAG-AFTRA debate and the strikes that happened around maintaining control of your performance and any iterations of that, or building upon that by a media company that might come later, it’s all on the table right now and still being discussed, still being worked out. I think in the short run, a lot of times if it’s in a brand deal, the key question is: if you are using generative AI to enhance in some way the final deliverable for the campaign, who has control over that? Who has final say and sign-off on how that likeness or that digital replica or that person’s voice is represented? And even outside of the brand space, we’ve seen actors like James Earl Jones signing over certain aspects like their voice and allowing it to continue to be used in these manners powered by generative AI as Darth Vader. And I think I saw something that Boy George was even starting up an AI company that allows musicians, the original recording artist, to rerecord new versions of their masters so that they don’t miss out on that revenue. It’s powered by generative AI, by taking their voice now, which is significantly different than it was back in the 80s, and using generative AI to make it sound closer to the original, but all based on their current performance. So I think it’s still an evolving area. And what’s interesting too is on the platform side, we’re seeing the early stages of platforms like Google starting to acknowledge and rely on the license grant contained in their terms of service for YouTube, which grants them broad rights to use the content to run their platform. So all that to be said, it’s still early stages. I’m very interested to see where we go from here in the future, especially from a global perspective as well.
Ken Suzan: Franklin, I could spend hours talking to you about this. You’re such a knowledgeable person on these topics. Maybe in a few years, will we connect again and talk further on AI and all the things that are yet to be developed?
Franklin Graves: Thank you. Yeah, it doesn’t have to be another decade. Maybe we can cut it to half a decade, given the pace at which technology is going now.
Ken Suzan: Sounds good, Franklin. Thanks again for being on the IP Fridays podcast.
Escucha IP Fridays - your intellectual property podcast about trademarks, patents, designs and much more, Otro podcast bursátil y muchos más podcasts de todo el mundo con la aplicación de radio.net

Descarga la app gratuita: radio.net
- Añadir radios y podcasts a favoritos
- Transmisión por Wi-Fi y Bluetooth
- Carplay & Android Auto compatible
- Muchas otras funciones de la app









































