I Never Liked You

Today we are joined by a very good friend Caitlin Peluffo! We talk her journey on Funny AF, getting dm’d by arianna grande, little house on the prarie, and doing some horrible gigs together. ENJOY!

Go to https://quince.com/inly for free shipping and 365-day returns

Check out Caitlins Special now!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8M5HKgLyjcI

🛍️ Buy our Merch!

https://ineverlikedyou.merchtable.com

🌍 Come See Matteo on Tour!

🎟️ https://www.matteolanecomedy.com/

🎧 Bonus Content

https://www.patreon.com/INeverLikedYouPodcast

🔗 Nick: https://linktr.ee/nicksmith09

🔗 Matteo: https://matteolanecomedy.com

🎬 Producer: https://www.instagram.com/chris.mp4

0:00 Intro
1:15 Caitlin Gets the Pass
1:48 Caitlin Is a Hard Worker!
2:36 Caitlin Goes on Funny AF!
4:54 Do You Have Kevin Hart's Number?
5:30 Caitlin Touched the Rock
6:30 Little House on the Prairie
8:59 Churning Butter
10:22 Wearing a Prairie Outfit to School
11:11 The Oregon Trail
14:23 Who Would Win in a Fight: Nick or Matteo?
16:19 Traveling with Caitlin Is So Much Fun
17:44 Caitlin's New Special, Prosciutto Rose
19:22 Ariana Grande DMed Caitlin
20:52 Frankie Grande
22:22 Ariana Grande
26:31 Nick's "Game"
27:43 The Beacon in P-Town
29:02 What Year Did You Start Doing Comedy?
29:07 Favorite Venue to Perform At
29:12 Worst Venue to Perform At
29:37 Favorite City to Perform In
29:40 Least Favorite City to Perform In
33:10 Favorite Person You've Opened For
33:15 Dream Person to Open For
33:59 Do You Think You Should Have Won Funny AF?
34:07 Do You Agree with Who Won?
35:38 Would You Go Back for Season 2?
36:19 Get Us on The Amazing Race!
37:25 Would You Date a Fan?
37:35 You Have to Choose: Matteo or Nick
38:31 Watch Caitlin's Special, Prosciutto Rose — Link Below!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Today we have Krysta Rodriguez on the podcast!! We talk about being on Broadway together, auditioning for spring awakening, and the most starstruck she’s ever been.

Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/inly/  #rulapod #ad 

🛍️ Buy our Merch!

https://ineverlikedyou.merchtable.com

🌍 Come See Matteo on Tour!

🎟️ https://www.matteolanecomedy.com/

🎧 Bonus Content

https://www.patreon.com/INeverLikedYouPodcast

🔗 Nick: https://linktr.ee/nicksmith09

🔗 Matteo: https://matteolanecomedy.com

🎬 Producer: https://www.instagram.com/chris.mp4

0:00 Intro

1:33 Nick Auditioned For Roxie

3:55 Krysta Is So Talented

5:25 Being Overwhelmed in Rehearsal

6:20 Dropping in Vs Originating A Broadway Role

9:44 Laughing on Broadway

12:09 Do You Prefer Dropping Into A Show Vs Originating?

15:37 Both Lizas in One Place

18:29 Being A Part of Spring Awakening

20:48 What Are Broadway Auditions Like

24:41 Do You Know How Special Spring Awakening Was at the Beginning?

26:15 Would You Play Annie?

27:59 The Ladder

31:38 How's It Been?

33:03 Nick's Rapid Fire Questions

34:06 First Broadway Show You Ever Did

34:14 Favorite Broadway Show You Ever Did

34:39 Dream Role

35:14 Who Is Someone You Would Love to Design For

36:00 Most Starstruck You've Ever Been

37:02 TV Or Theatre?

38:01 Designing Broadway Dressing Rooms

41:01 Smash, Who Should Have Been Marilyn

42:02 Who's a Better Liza?

43:30 Most Talented Costar

45:20 I Think Billy Is Gay

46:49 How Do You Feel About Our Studio?

48:28 How's Chicago Going?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Today we are talking about Pride! So many companiues arent doing pride anymore and it’s a shame. Soooo we decided to take it in our hands and come up with some new slogans for their companies! Enjoy!

New deals and styles are listed every day, so don't wait. Download the Poshmark app today and use code inly10 when you sign up to get $10 off your first purchase. https://www.poshmark.com/inly10

Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/inly #rulapod #ad

🛍️ Buy our Merch!

https://ineverlikedyou.merchtable.com

🌍 Come See Matteo on Tour!

🎟️ https://www.matteolanecomedy.com/

🎧 Bonus Content

https://www.patreon.com/INeverLikedYouPodcast

🔗 Nick: https://linktr.ee/nicksmith09

🔗 Matteo: https://matteolanecomedy.com

🎬 Producer: https://www.instagram.com/chris.mp4

0:00 Intro

1:13 Carrie is the WORST in Sex and the City

2:09 Pride Month!

3:50 Nick's First Improv Show

7:58 Making New Pride Slogans For Companies

8:30 Dove Soap

9:18 Arby's

9:50 Burger King

10:32 Head & Shoulders

11:29 Neutrogena

11:50 Tide

11:58 Bounty

12:47 Febreze

13:24 Kraft

17:24 Chobani

17:37 Red Bull

18:54 We Should Go Out One Night!

20:03 McDonald's

22:51 Chipotle

25:17 Taco Bell
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Sooo on todays episode we talk about what has been going on in our lives recenetly because it so much has been going on. We hope you enjoy this one and always be kind!! Enjoy!

Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling today at https://shopify.com/inly

https://mengotomars.com | 50% off for life + Free Shipping + 3 Free Gifts

🛍️ Buy our Merch!

https://ineverlikedyou.merchtable.com

🌍 Come See Matteo on Tour!

🎟️ https://www.matteolanecomedy.com/

🎧 Bonus Content

https://www.patreon.com/INeverLikedYouPodcast

🔗 Nick: https://linktr.ee/nicksmith09

🔗 Matteo: https://matteolanecomedy.com

🎬 Producer: https://www.instagram.com/chris.mp4

0:00 Intro

0:16 We Found a (Small) Sanctuary!

1:02 Nick Scares Himself

2:28 Nick Tries to Do the Muppets

4:02 Matteo Is on Broadway!!!

8:55 Nick Major Life Update!

16:17 Matteo Life Update!

16:54 What Does Nick Know?

19:38 Mexico City with Atsuko

21:34 Updates?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

We have started a voicemail where you can leave us questions and ask for advice! We really enjoyed this episode and hope you did too, let us know if you would like to see more of these in the future! 

Leave us a voicemail with your questions or advice requests! We loved making this episode and hope you enjoyed it too. Let us know if you want more! A note on voicemails: We listen to all of them, but tend to pick ones that are lighthearted and not too long, unless it's a truly wild story.

https://theperfectjean.nyc/INLY15

🛍️ Buy our Merch!

https://ineverlikedyou.merchtable.com

Come see Nicks Show June 20th!

https://www.ticketmaster.com/hear-me-out-hosted-by-nick-brooklyn-new-york-06-20-2026/event/300064A4511BECED?_gl=1*kgrd03*_ga*MTQwNDI4NzYyNC4xNzc4MDg2MDI5*_ga_C1T806G4DF*czE3NzgwODYwMjkkbzEkZzAkdDE3NzgwODYwMjkkajYwJGwwJGgw

🌍 Come See Matteo on Tour!

🎟️ https://www.matteolanecomedy.com/

🎧 Bonus Content

https://www.patreon.com/INeverLikedYouPodcast

🔗 Nick: https://linktr.ee/nicksmith09

🔗 Matteo: https://matteolanecomedy.com

🎬 Producer: https://www.instagram.com/chris.mp4

0:00 Intro

3:04 Voicemail 1 - Sue Calls In

3:44 Voicemail 2 - Somethinggggggggg

4:14 Voicemail 3 - Can I Make a Nick Paperdoll?

5:36 Voicemail 4 - What Is the Largest Animal You Could Fight?

9:37 Voicemail 5 - How To Tell Someone They Failed a Drug Test?

10:40 Voicemail 6 - How To Get Over a Breakup When the D Is Sooo Good?

11:50 Voicemail 7 - Is Nick Trying To Get Smarter?

15:07 Voicemail 8 - What Reality Show Would You Go On?

17:38 Voicemail 9 - Moving Into College

18:22 Voicemail 10 - Is Nick OK?????????????

19:42 Voicemail 11 - Nick Gets His Flowers

20:38 Voicemail 12 - What's Your Favorite Muppet?

21:49 Voicemail 13 - Craigslist Haircut

23:05 Voicemail 14 - Nick Still Doesn't Understand Lake Michigan

27:17 Voicemail 15 - What Pokemon Trainer Would You Be?

29:48 Voicemail 16
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices